You really don't believe in America or free markets. Only global manipulated markets. You are a gloBULList right?
Now you are throwing strawmen arguments - if people come out of retirement and that fills the gap - fine by me no need to import. I specifically said there is a shortage - I don’t know why you assumed I would exclude the retired in filling that vacancy.
I am anti globalist and against free trade - I am a Pat Buchanan type or a Steve Bannon type. I just gave an example in the modern world where there maybe a need for immigration. But for the most part we don’t have an empty frontier to fill like 150 years ago nor do we have labor intensive factory jobs unfilled. So the need for mass migration is non existent for America. There maybe needs for targeted migration here or there on a limited basis is what I am saying but you seem to treat that as me advocating for open borders policy which is stupid on your part, no offense.