“Sounds like a CATHOLIC dream pick to me.”
So, if she were Lutheran, you’d obviously write:
Sounds like a LUTHERAN dream pick to me.
If she were Methodist, you’d write:
Sounds like a METHODIST dream pick to me.
If she were Anglican, you’d write:
Sounds like a ANGLICAN dream pick to me.
If she were Jewish:
Sounds like a JEWISH dream pick to me.
And, if she were Mormon:
Sounds like a MORMON dream pick to me.
Hmm. Smells like BIGOTRY to me.
BIGOTRY You say? In capital letters?
Perhaps you confuse BIGOTRY with biases, preferences, and personal beliefs.
All of which are perfectly natural and normal values.