I see four men standing close to each other, two well illuminated and quite clear, the other two poorly lit so they are seen in sillhouette. What they are calling Noonan must be a man with no shoulders or arms and indistinct legs.
He is facing the camera yet unlike the other two men looking the same direction, his face is dark with heavy shadows.
Looking at the ground behind one of men is duffle bag, possibly a mail sack. “Noonan’s body” looks a lot like that white bag and there is some sort of sign partially blocking Noonan’s “face”. Rather than a man I would say thats a mailbag vertically hanging on a hook.
The seated figure could be male or female you cannot see the face.
Not sure where the maybe 38ft object is on a ship.
I don’t see anything that looks clearly like the plane in the stamp #4 photo. I thought the person all in white was a woman with a big hat but that’s a man with another man’s head behind him. The alleged Noonan appears to be leaning up against the post with one leg up to keep any weight off it. I’m not convinced the person ID’d as Earhart is not a man. Awfully broad-shouldered but then if I was sitting on a dock, I might have my shoulders in a hunched position while my hands held onto the edge for support.
I just don’t see anything here that says “bingo”. I see something that if you are trying to make all the pieces fit, you think is Earhart then you have to find someone you think is Noonan then you have to find something that looks like the plane but if you’re not convinced the first ID is Earhart then the whole supposition falls apart.