There is no doubt they were taken in New York City in 1958 because the woman in those photographs appeared in "Exotique Magazine" #23 on page 22. Here is a similar picture FROM 1958.
And there are plenty more photographs of this same woman from that same era, and there are photographs of other women sitting on that same furniture.
This Myth has been busted. The credit for busting it must be given to Loren C., a former freeper, and I believe an attorney in Atlanta Georgia.
How did Joel Gilbert make matches with the woodwork and floorboards in FMD’s house?
How many people have sofas of which there are not thousands or tens of thousands of copies?
That’s not the woman Joel Gilbert identifies as SAD. Nobody denies that FMD took photos of other women. Also, where was Exotique published?
I read the original post. Convincing arguments.
One thing: The fact that Exotique was published in NYC is no indication that any photo published in it was taken in NYC.