Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Cyberman
How can "providing the FBI with a signed iPhone Software file, recovery bundle or other Software image File (“SIF”)" possibly be interpreted in such a way that the FBI never gets custody of the software "provided" to it?

It's a virtual world nowadays. "Provided" does not have to mean "custody." Indeed, the order specifically allows Apple to retain custody of the phone throughout the duration.

If the judge was insistent that the FBI be given physical custody of the software, why would she let Apple inc keep the phone?

People keep trying to read stuff in to the order that is not really within the spirit of the order.

I do admit that Apple needs to use their legal staff to file a motion for the judge to further clarify the order so as to explicitly protect Apple's Intellectual Property rights, but that is a simple thing for them to do.

354 posted on 03/02/2016 9:30:08 AM PST by DiogenesLamp ("of parents owing allegiance to no other sovereignty.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 347 | View Replies ]


To: DiogenesLamp; Ray76; Cyberman; DesertRhino; palmer; SteveH; itsahoot; IncPen; ...
It's a virtual world nowadays. "Provided" does not have to mean "custody." Indeed, the order specifically allows Apple to retain custody of the phone throughout the duration.

"Provided" has never, ever meant "custody", DiogenesLamp. It is not even a synonym of "custody".


DiogenesLamp, sitting on the wall in Wonderland,
expounding on his meanings of words!

Now, you want to alter ENGLISH to your own "DiogneseLamp's Dictionary of Delusional Definitions of Common English Words—2016 Revised Edition"

pro·vid·ing
prəˈvīdiNG

conjunction
conjunction: providing on the condition or understanding that.
"we have the team that can win the championship, providing we avoid bad injuries"

provvide
prəˈvīd
verb
gerund or present participle: providing
1. make available for use; supply.
"these clubs provide a much appreciated service for this area"

synonyms: supply, give, issue, furnish, come up with, dispense, bestow, impart, produce, yield, bring forth, bear, deliver, donate, contribute, pledge, advance, spare, part with, allocate, distribute, allot, put up;

antonyms: refuse, withhold

1a. equip or supply someone with (something useful or necessary).
"we were provided with a map of the area"

synonyms: equip, furnish, issue, supply, outfit;

antonyms: deprive

1b. present or yield (something useful).
"neither will provide answers to these problems"

synonyms: make available, present, offer, afford, give, add, bring, yield, 1c. impart
"the test may provide the answer"

2. make adequate preparation for (a possible event).
"new qualifications must provide for changes in technology"

synonyms: prepare, allow, make provision, be prepared, arrange, get ready, plan, cater
"we have provided for further restructuring"

2a. supply sufficient money to ensure the maintenance of (someone).
"Emma was handsomely provided for in Frank's will"

synonyms: feed, nurture, nourish;

antonyms: neglect

2b. (of a law) enable or allow (something to be done).

3. stipulate in a will or other legal document.
"the order should be varied to provide that there would be no contact with the father"

synonyms: stipulate, lay down, make it a condition, require, order, ordain, demand, prescribe, state, specify
"the legislation provides that factories must be kept clean"

4. CHRISTIAN CHURCH historical appoint an incumbent to (a benefice).

Origin

late Middle English (also in the sense ‘prepare to do, get ready’): from Latin providers ‘foresee, attend to,’ from pro- ‘before’ + voider ‘to see.’

NOWHERE in the definition of Providing or Provide, its root, do you find "CUSTODY", you delusional cretan.

People keep trying to read stuff in to the order that is not really within the spirit of the order.

YOU, sir, are the prime offender.

We have fallen through the looking glass and we are now in Wonderland.

377 posted on 03/02/2016 8:54:23 PM PST by Swordmaker (This tag line is a Microsoft insult free zone... but if the insults to Mac users continue..)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 354 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson