Replies

It is the tip of the iceberg. Immigration is not an unalloyed good. The Left and the RINOs have successfully stifled discussion on the issue branding the opposition as bigots and nativists.

In Europe, the discussion of immigration is far more open and rational. In the UK, there is actually a political consensus among the major parties that immigration must be reduced. In fact, Labor has criticized Cameron for not meeting his reduction targets. Unthinkable at one time. How was this achieved? A small party, the BNP, started the slogan, "British Jobs for British workers." It changed the political dynamics and touched a nerve in the populace. Jeff Sessions is proposing a similar approach here.

The NYT attacked Sessions as being anti-immigrant and a racist; Sessions responded in a letter to the NYT:

In 1970, fewer than 1 in 21 United States residents were born abroad. Five years from today, the Census Bureau estimates that more than one in seven United States residents will have been born abroad. Eight years from today, the share of the population that is foreign-born will rise above any level ever before recorded and keep surging.

It defies reason to argue that the record admission of new foreign workers has no negative effect on the wages of American workers, including the wages of past immigrants hoping to climb into the middle class. Why would many of the largest business groups in the United States spend millions lobbying for the admission of more foreign workers if such policies did not cut labor costs?

The New York Times once plainly acknowledged as much, writing in a 2000 editorial: “Between about 1980 and 1995, the gap between the wages of high school dropouts and all other workers widened substantially. Prof. George Borjas of Harvard estimates that almost half of this trend can be traced to immigration of unskilled workers.”

Since that sentence was published, another 18 million immigrants have arrived in the United States, while the share of Americans in the work force has declined almost five percentage points.

Reuters says Americans, by a nearly 3-to-1 margin, wish to see immigration reduced, not increased. Policy makers and voters should be openly discussing this issue of national interest. Efforts to intimidate Americans into silence will no longer work.

JEFF SESSIONS