Chastity, Hope, Prudence, Obedience, Charity. All pretty common names in the old days.
My personal favorite, though English Puritan rather than American, was the son of Praise-God Barebones who he named If-Christ-had-not-died-for-thee-thou-hadst-been-damned Barebones.
Oddly, he chose to go by the name Nicolas when he grew up. Made a name for himself as an early economist.
His brother was named Jesus-Christ-came-into-the-world- to-save Barebones.
Those Barebones names were pretty ambitious. lol
Coincidentally, just the other day, I was thinking about what I might’ve named three daughters, if I had had daughters instead of three sons. And Faith, Hope, and Charity came to mind. Not that I would’ve picked those names; years ago I had other names in mind for daughters. But they would’ve been nice names for girls. And now, here on this forum, coincidentally, today there’s a discussion on those types of names. Surreal.