Posted on 12/28/2014 6:53:44 PM PST by smoothsailing
Exactly seventy years ago, Allied forces in Europe experienced an all-too-common occurrence in war: a huge intelligence failure that led to a surprise attack, followed by a horrific battlefield disaster. That it was transformed into victory by the Allies
was due, in large measure, to the incredible bravery of young Americans, who were outnumbered, outgunned, and fighting in some of the worst physical conditions of World War II.
Seventy years later, the Battle of the Bulge is not as celebrated as the D-Day invasion or Iwo Jima, but it was far deadlier than either of those battles. Indeed, it was the costliest encounter for the United States in the entire war. More than 19,000 Americans were killed in the thick Ardennes forest between December 16, 1944, and January 25, 1945, 62,000 were wounded, and more than 26,000 were either captured or missing.
It was the last great offensive by Germany, which attempted to cut the Allied armies on the Western Front in half. A large part of its initial success came from the complete secrecy in which it was orchestrated. There were signs that should have been picked up beforehand—the code-breaking machine Ultra provided cables that might have tipped off the Allies, and there were even intelligence officers who predicted a counteroffensive at that time. Neither was taken seriously by the high command. The Allies had pushed through France and into Belgium in just six months following the Normandy invasion, and GIs talked about the possibility of being home for Christmas.
The reason it is called the Battle of the Bulge is that an obvious “bulge” was created on the maps that many people followed daily back home. The Germans had a two-to-one troop advantage in the initial assault, and they had more tanks and artillery as well. That part of the front was lightly defended by the Allies. The Germans, however, had fewer troops in reserve, which would prove consequential. It was the equivalent of a Hail Mary pass, and it almost succeeded.
One key factor that should have worked against the Germans was the almost complete control of the skies that the Allies commanded over Europe by that point. That domination came at a high price after two years of horrific air battles. But even that worked in Germany’s favor at the start of the Bulge because the weather turned awful. Heavy overcast followed by bitter cold temperatures grounded practically every plane in Europe. With complete surprise, superior numbers, and terrible weather, the Germans devastated everything in their path.
In some cases, strict orders for utmost speed led to massacres, the worst of which took place in the small Belgian town of Malmedy. There, a unit of the First SS Panzer Division, commanded by Joachim Peiper, could not be bothered with prisoners. In a snow-covered field, SS troops machine-gunned 84 Americans to death. This led to vicious, take-no-prisoners fighting on both sides over the next month. Peiper was convicted of war crimes in a military tribunal in 1946 and sentenced to death. The order was later commuted because of efforts by both governments to move past the war, and he was released after 12 years in prison. In 1976, after careers at Volkswagen and Porsche, Peiper, a Nazi hardliner, was shot to death by unknown assailants, and then his home was burned to the ground. No one has ever taken responsibility.
One of America’s most courageous moments—and it was truly heroic—came at Bastogne with the 101st Airborne. Vastly outnumbered and running low on everything from food and medical supplies to ammunition, the paratroopers held their ground and the strategic city never fell into enemy hands. That stand is one of the few parts of the Bulge that has been re-created by Hollywood, first in the 1949 classic Battleground, starring Van Johnson and James Whitmore, and, more recently, in the HBO series Band of Brothers.
Although some green troops placed at the front, and even some with combat experience, completely folded in the wake of the massive German onslaught, there were Bastogne-like stands throughout the Bulge that were crucial in slowing the German advance. Just as critical were American supplies, which, once they started moving again, seemed limitless. It was almost exclusively a German-American fight, and it was the Americans that eventually gained the upper hand. Afterwards, Winston Churchill said, “This is undoubtedly the greatest American battle of the war and will, I believe, be regarded as an ever-famous American victory.” Churchill was wrong on his last thought; other battles have surpassed the Bulge in our national memory.
In a long war filled with great drama, there was one moment that should always be remembered, especially during the congressional debates on military spending that have taken place in every year since 1945. When the weather finally broke, America’s Army Air Force was unleashed. On December 24, Christmas Eve, the United States flew 1,138 tactical sorties (fighters) and an astounding 2,442 heavy bomber sorties.
Most wars are fought individually or in small groups. Rarely do participants see or even understand the grand scope and design swirling around them. Just witnessing this vast air armada had a huge psychological effect on the soldiers below on both sides. Few people in history have ever seen anything like it—before or since—and one of them was my late father, Capt. Sidney P. Kozak.
Like the other men of that era, my father kept most of his stories to himself, but he shared one that still gives me chills. On that day when the skies cleared, he said the men around him heard and even felt the sound before they understood its source. Then, suddenly, the entire sky filled with planes from one end to the other. He actually waved his arm across some imaginary horizon to add emphasis. And they were all flying in one direction.
“I couldn’t believe one country could build that many airplanes,” he told me years later, still in awe (and he had no concept of the massive numbers flying over the Pacific at the same time). Then he paused in his story and shared a very personal moment with a son who rarely, if ever, heard anything personal from this man.
“It was the most religious experience of my life,” he said, looking far off and not at me.
It is impossible to quantify the impact of a sight like that on an individual, especially given the situation. But watching wave after wave pushing across the sky, flying in strict, regimental formation, with their contrails streaming behind them for miles, electrified the men below and gave them courage. These young Americans were no less cold and hungry and miserable than their forebears at Valley Forge on another Christmas 167 years earlier.
And they were no less their equals.
Warren Kozak is the author of LeMay: The Life and Wars of General Curtis LeMay (Regnery) and Presidential Courage: Three Speeches That Changed America.
Apparently, Bradley underestimated the Germans and was caught off guard. It was his blunder. Also, Patton’s intelligence officer suspected that something was up but was never taken seriously.
Also, for whatever reason the British stayed out of the battle. They could have offered support but they didn’t. The American army was on its own.
IIRC, for the Germans, it was a two-fold objective:
1) Deny the port facilities to the allies
2.) Take control of the resources there (fuel, supplies, etc)
Ya. But didn’t Montgomery stay out of the battle? I read that the American army got little support from Monty.
Battle of the Bulge ping.
I’ve been to the Gettysburg Battlefield several times over the years. The experience has been an intense one each time. The spiritual nature of it is beyond my ability to describe, but I believe I understand what is meant by those who speak of having a religious experience in similar moments.
I think it was mostly in the American area but I don’t think they would have given Montgomery command over all forces during the battle if the British were not in it.
Rommel committed suicide in October 44, two months before the Bulge. He had been seriously wounded in July 44 and was essentially not in active command after that. Rommel was given a cyanide capsule as an alternative to a kanagroo court trial in front of a People’s Court.
My dad is 90, and arrived in Europe just after the Battle, and took part in the mopping- up efforts in Germany and Belgium. Had he been drafted a few months earlier, who knows? His abiding memory was the heavy snow and bitter cold of the winter of ‘44-’45.
By this time we were pretty much committed to unconditional surrender, nobody had the heart by this time to cut out the Soviets, though I’m sure there were many who would have loved to do just that.
God Bless your dad, bigbob.
My dad has passed on but was in the Army and was actually stateside during the Bulge. He was born in 1909 and was drafted after Pearl.
“Fresh from commanding the 21st Army group during the Normandy invasion, and having suffered an awful defeat in September as his troops attempted to cross the Rhine, Montgomery took temporary command of the northern shoulder of American and British troops in the Ardennes. He immediately fell into a familiar pattern, failing to act spontaneously for fear of not being sufficiently prepared. Montgomery was afraid to move before the German army had fully exhausted itself, finally making what American commanders saw as only a belated counterattack against the enemy. As the weather improved, American air cover raided German targets on the ground, which proved the turning point in the Allied victory. Monty eventually cut across northern Germany all the way to the Baltic and accepted the German surrender in May.”
http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/monty-holds-a-press-conference
Indeed the Greatest Generation!
Wow! Powerful!
Thanks for posting the prayer! B^)
Good point. He may have not contributed to the offensive. Apparently, he had a skull fracture. But in a pinch, he might have been brought into the action.
Yes Montgomery took the credit and that was probably a mistake since American troops were more responsible for the victory than any other.
On the other hand, Montgomery was in fact the ground commander of all forces during the battle, including American ones, so I can see his point.
I think Montgomery was better than history has painted him.
I saw an interview of the German General in command of the entire German army. He was in prison at the time. One question they asked him was who did he think was the best Allied general. He simply answered “Montgomery and Patton”.
Interestingly, both Churchill and FDR were separately and secretly negotiating with Stalin for how to divide up post war Eastern Europe. Both were duped. Stalin made promises but had other plans.
I don’t know frankly if FDR and Churchill had much choice....there were very few in America or Britain that would have had the stomach to take on the Soviets.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.