Posted on 07/15/2014 12:01:59 PM PDT by Cronos
Opinion polls suggest the Scots will decide against leaving, but it is the nationalists who have fire in their bellies, and Alex Salmond, the leader of the Scottish National Party (SNP), is a strong finisher. The campaign has been a bad-tempered one, marked by growing Scottish anger at English complacency and indifference while English resentment of Scottish whingeing and freeloading has risen
On economics, the nationalists say that Scots will be £1,000 a year better-off per head if they go it alone. That number, however, is based on implausible assumptions about the oil price, Scotlands debt burden, demography and productivity. The British governments estimate that Scots would be £1,400 a year better off per head if they stay in is based on more realistic assumptions. Scotlands population is older and sicker than the British average, and productivity 11% lower than that of the rest of Britain. As a result, the state spends around £1,200 more per head on Scots than on the average Briton.
It is, of course, possible that independence would cure Scotlands entitlement culture ..its two dominant partiesthe SNP and Labour.. statist philosophies are more likely to drive Edinburghs fund managers, Aberdeens oil-services engineers and other talented Scots south. Independence would also impose one-off costs: a new Scottish state would have to set up an army, a welfare system, a currency and much else
..Resentment of England lurks in the backdrop of Scottish nationalism. But in the foreground is not broadsword and targe but socialist dogma... Scotland is different from England because it is more left-wingand only independence can deliver the social democracy Scots want....promising Scandinavian-style public services supported by taxation closer to American levels. That is fantasy, not socialism.
(Excerpt) Read more at economist.com ...
The NPR report I heard seemed to lean towards Scotland staying because they need the Welfare money from the UK.
a new Scottish state would have to set up an army, a welfare system, a currency and much else”
Army? They will depend on the Royal Navy, RAF, and military to protect them. The UK will be treated as a buffer state.
Welfare? They are promising everyone free money. I guess oil money is what they are hoping to pay them off with.
Currency? They will either hop onto the Euro or leech off of the Pound.
“Macedonia will reunite with Bulgaria”
Although Macedonians see Bulgarians as kinsmen and fellow Slavs they are not the same nor will there be any peaceful reunification.
I know quite a few Macedonians from the Greater Chicago area and none see themselves as a part of Greater Bulgaria.
Sean Connery/Rowdy Roddy Piper 2016
And Harry Potter books will be unwelcome in government schools.
“Belgium will permanently break with the north becoming Flanders”
That one will probably happen before the end of the decade, with half of what is now the country being majority-Muslim before 2025.
Let them go. They’ll be begging to be let in less than a decade.
But by then it will be too late. Scotland will be in the EU and the break-up of the rest of the UK will be well underway
Edward I is going to have to come back from the grave and kick their butts all over again.
Hopefully not.
I think Scotland is going to have to learn a lesson the hard way. Them leaving probably makes England more financially secure. I heard it was the same with Wales.
I just do not understand how it will be “independent” if its part of the EU.
Lancashire. Not Lancastershire. The war of the roses are over mate.
Wales will never leave the UK. There is not enough appetite for it, plus who’d pay for their free NHS presecriptions?
Again?.
I am not a Scots Nationalist, a patriot though and I think youll find the Scots failed to be conquered by Edward and the English.
Edward may have won Dunbar and Falkirk, but he also had the massive defeat at Stirling Bridge, other smaller defeats, and ultimately Scotland prevailed.
Yes, we can. And it has worked for 307 years.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.