Replies

Triple: "That point is moot in relation to this argument.
Virginia had the right to secede, and exercised that right.
It was a lawful action on the part of Virginia."

I don't agree, nor did many Virginians at the time, especially those in Western Virginia.
But regardless, it's your point which is moot in relation to this discussion, FRiend.

That's because, Constitutionally, you have a right to say any d*mn fool thing you want to say: go ahead, take your soap box to a street corner somewhere, and declare your secession from whatever it is that you want to secede from -- from the United States, from the world, from mankind, h*ll you can declare secession from the whole Universe, if you want to, and the Constitution will not touch you.

Provided, provided, provided FRiend, that you don't break any laws.
Now, once you begin breaking laws, then the government has some authority it will exert over you, unpleasant authority, which you will not like.
And if you go so far as to start and declare war on your government, then it might well end in your death, which, of course, will accomplish your total secession from everything.
I'd call that suicide by secession. Don't do it.

But that is precisely what Virginia (and Tennessee) did.
In one "brilliant" stroke, they voted to both secede and declare war on the United States.
And the results are that Virginia and Tennessee arguably suffered more from the Civil War than any other states.

But, at least you can't say: they didn't get what they wanted.