[Theo]

Do you smoke?

[Just another Joe]

Theo, the thrust of the anti-smokers argument is the physical damage caused by second hand smoke.
There is no definitive scientific proof that second hand smoke has ever cuased damage to anyone that does not have a pre-existing medical condition.

The real argument behind most anti-smoker's stance is that they just don't like the smell.

I have posted on this for many years and know the science, the studies, and have debated the point many times.

Other posters on this thread have pointed out what the debate is about, private property rights.
Not the rights of the woman who lived under you but the rights of the landlord who owned the property.