It seems to me that some mortals want to apply the laws of logic to God, e.g. the Law of Identity or the Law of the Excluded Middle --- as if God, the Creator of such laws, is restricted by His own Creation.
Man is not the measure of God.
I think it's worth noting that when it really mattered He CHOSE to abide by the exact laws that He set for us.
He DID NOT need to become fully Man through the Incarnation.
He DID NOT have to suffer and die on His Cross.
He DID NOT have to be Resurrected and Ascend into Heaven.
He could have saved mankind WITHOUT any of these things, He CHOSE not to.
He CHOSE to be fully Man and sacrifice Himself out of His love for us.
Indeed and so true, dearest sister in Christ. And it's even worse than that — some use a sort of mindless "cookie-cutter logic," for example: "God cannot be tempted by evil, but Jesus Christ was; therefore, Jesus Christ is not God."
It seems to me to apply logic and the laws of nature to God — i.e., to the Source whereby they came into existence — is to falsify the divine character from the get-go. Ineluctably, such a maneuver "makes man the measure" of God.
There is no way for man to "measure" the I Am That I Am — pure self-sufficient eternal Being. It seems to me we humans cannot even conceptualize such a thing, let alone make it subject to the ordinary rules we understand from our purely human experience.
Thank you ever so much for your most perceptive observation, dearest sister in Christ!