I vote for an atheist over a muslim.
Also, it depends on what type of atheist he/she was. Was it an atheist who respected Christians? Or was it one of those atheists who belittled everything Christian?
There are a few conservative atheist FReepers and there’s a big difference between them and the atheists on the left.
Conservative atheists have respect for Christianity, the left hates Christianity and Judaism but loves and respects every other religion just for spite.
Good questions.