[Tenacious 1]

"If anyone thinks there's a hint of tweaking the data for non-scientific purposes, they are free to produce an analysis showing that Earth isn't warming," adds Michael Oppenheimer,

That isn't the refute, a$$bagger. The refute is that 1) is not caused by CO2 and humans and 2) It has been warmer as recently as the Medieval Warming Period and the cycles are normal.

BTW - Analysis showing the earth warming has been replicated. Unfortunately, it showed that your hockeystick missed the Medieval warming period and some cooling again during the industrial age. When you said they were wrong, they asked for your data so they could prove it with your own data. But, alas, first it was lost, then it was confidential, then it was proprietary.

[Red Badger]

But, alas, first it was lost, then it was confidential, then it was proprietary.

Then it was hacked.............