Replies

Unfortunately, a lot more people than Hanson talk this way. Even Glenn Beck referred to Obama as "my President" early on.

I don't have a President - the United States does. Barack Obama, and all his predecessors, holds an office defined by the Constitution. He has no relationship with or obligation to me personally, nor I him. This is true of any President, whether I like him or voted for him or neither. Furthermore, the President is certainly not my Commander-in-Chief - he is the Commander in Chief of the "Army and Navy", which I am no longer a part of.

Now, Joe Wilson was an officer in the National Guard until recently, but I'm pretty sure he's retired now. If he is still an officer, then Obama would indeed be his Commander in Chief, but then arguably only when the South Carolina National Guard has been "called into the actual Service of the United States." I also doubt that's what Hanson meant.

All that said, I'm more than willing to cut Professor Hanson some slack, partly because the use of the idiom "my President" is so widespread, and partly because he's right on so many other things that it seems silly to get hung up on one phrase.