Posted on 05/09/2009 7:41:37 AM PDT by Publius
But if you fixture it into a mill configuration, it isn’t a lathe anymore. The thing you describe sounds like the world’s largest Shopmaster more than it does a lathe.
True, but I’d hate to have to do something as long as lathe ways in that kind of setup.
You are right, thunkit. Didn’t think of that. Which is why I went to the Inventory Control Dept. as soon as possible. :)
Let me put it a little differently. I personally would have a greater confidence of succeeding in making a lathe on a mill than I would in making a mill on a lathe. Maybe it’s more of an issue with me personally.
I had the same reaction to the Lathe comment as you. I worked with lathes and milling machines working my way through college in the 70s in a machine shop.
The lathe can create parts, but it can’t create the electric motor that runs it.
And a foot powered lathe is not going to create high finish machine tools.
Apart from that, the lathe was the most satisfying machine to operate based on what you could create.
I was taught by a navy machinist that the idea was to keep the number of machine tools on a ship to a minimum. They could rebuild most battle damaged parts with basic equipment. Damn good machinists in the navy.
If you want me to respond make an objective point.
ML/NJ
A gratuitous insult is not objective.
Rearden would understand this discussion and probably add to it, that is what he does.He deals with rational processes.
OTOH, Jim Taggert wouldn't, he doesn't use concrete, rational thought as a way of solving a problem.
The clash of these two distinct thought processes is the basis of AS.
As a machinist, you couldn't consider emotion in the design and manufacture of a part.
Jim Taggert couldn't design and build a part because he would have to include irrational elements thus spoiling it's intended use.
Taggert could, however use others to build it for him.
To do so he needs to make them feel as if they are indebted to him in some manner.
That is what the looters and moochers do.
If you look at my previous posts, I'm sure that you'll see that I don't agree with Ragnars destructive actions, I'm with you on this. The destruction of wealth is not condoned by the producers because they understand that it is a regression that will have to once again be overcome if they can continue living as they do.
How can we deal with irrationality in a world that we view as rational? Something has to give.
Correct. It's back to basics.
...it seems the whole structure of financial wealth ie:401k's,etc. is what is being wiped out because it is based on debt as money.
Correct again. Likewise, our whole fiat currency system is based on debt, which has exploded out of control.
...even if GM goes bankrupt the Machine Tools and Dies and Blue Prints remain.
Correct. And what medium of exchange do we use to restart the business, pay the employees and sell the cars? The current fiat money supply is based on unsustainable debt. How do we start again? (You can see what I'm leading to.)
Read Maximum Feasible Misunderstanding, by Daniel Patrick Moynihan
I think Ragnar's actions square with Galt's principle that force may (must) be resorted to when force has been used against one, in this case, through unjust tax law backed by the government's guns. As you say, his fellow strikers disagree with his methods, but primarily because they pose an unwarranted danger to him personally. But, of course, he is free to pursue his understanding of the correct action.
Kirk
I was on a Yahoo group once that had to do with Peak Oil, and the expectation (hope on many people’s part...) that running out of oil would bring the world back to the medieval and a huge percentage of the world’s population would die as a result of lack of medicines and other essentials.
I was thinking at the time what I would do if anything approaching a pandemic like this were to happen, and the “things” didn’t matter so much as the know-how. And to what I think is one of Rand’s points, if people know how to build things (steel, rail, tools, etc.), then it WILL come back once the impediments are removed. I actually found myself wanting to stock up more on old-time How-To books to be able to maintain my own tools, buildings, equipment, and also how people constructed their basic tools back a couple of hundred years ago. I’m a bit concerned about the fact that SO MUCH of our industrial plant has moved to China and wonder if we could restart at this point. I think so, but am not fully confident of that fact.
Another generation gone and we might not. For instance, I can keep my old Mercedes diesel going forever if I have the basic parts available, and they would be for some time to come. Most of my children’s generation couldn’t. We are really losing the knowledge of doing for ourselves, one generation at a time.
Of course, necessity sometimes is truly the mother of invention, and my son’s generation may have to learn how to restart, and those who can will percolate to the top. The others will either go away or be poor.
“Civilization is always only one generation away from barbarism.” - Roland Bainton
I interpreted Ragnar’s car having a “million dollar engine” to mean that, like everything else, the Strikers work at perfection. Ragnar or someone else would keep the engine of the car in tip-top shape because that is what they do. Not that it was the mystery engine. The creator would never have let a working model out amongst the Looters. Too much risk. Also, Rand is setting up a metaphor here. The “engine of the world” powering a rust-bucket jalopy.
I have a theory that I've used often in raising my boys and running my little production shop. I call it the "Coin of the Realm" theory. When my boys would complain that they had a bad teacher, they weren't learning anything or they were bored I would ask them, "You're in school, what's the coin of the realm"? And they would answer "grades". Correct. Their mother wouldn't agree with me. She would say "learning". And I would say in a perfect world that would be true. But grades are what determines going to the next level. Getting into college. It would be nice if along with good grades you would get some education into their thick heads. But in the end you are judged in school by your grades. Stop bitching and accept the reality of the situation. You are in a school. Get the grades up. The Coin of the Realm.
In my shop the Coin of the Realm is quality production. I tell new guys that they don't have to kiss my ass or suck up to me or anyone else. I don't even have to like them. And I point out one of my best employees that has a nasty personality that nobody cares much for but he gets the job done better than anyone. That's all the counts. Just produce good parts as fast as possible and you will make your money and get along just fine. In my shop production is everything. The Coin of the Realm.
Which brings me to money and Francisco d'Anconia. He correctly identified that money, properly understood and representative of value ( honest work. Production of life sustaining goods and services) is a moral good. Just like grades, properly understood and representative of value ( honest study, knowledge )is a moral good.
The proper Coin of the Realm in an economy is honest money. Earned by honest, productive, quality labor.
But if the grades are given out by favor or influence they cease to be a moral good. If money has been created out of thin air by a privileged elite and given out to other privileged elite bankers, The Coin of the Realm has been subverted. That's where we find ourselves. The Coin of the Realm in our economy isn't production and honest labor but Pull and Who You Know. Just look at the days newspapers to see who is getting subsidies and fiat money. Atlas Shrugged has come home to roost
And as many of us have pointed out, this system is drowning in it's own poison. What will and should replace it ? Gold coins? Paper currency backed by precious metals? I don't think that solves the problem. Because even if we back the currency with some solid commodity yet allow the creation and control of the Coin of the Realm to stay in the hands of the politicians ( Legal Tender Laws come to mind) and bankers we will never return money to the moral good it should be as described by d'Anconia.
IMO the only true "money" - I shall, as Rand would say, define my terms- ie:a store of value and a medium of exchanges.....will come into the market naturally after the production of wealth begins again. Maybe through script that represents gold coins or bullets or water. In the end honest bankers will emerge to hold the "savings" of the producers and issue receipts that can be traded. They would be true stores of value and reliable mediums of exchange
And presto! in short order The Coin of the Realm will be real money representing honest labor and real goods and services.
On the Day After, when nobody will take fiat greenbacks anymore, there will still be farmers and miners and makers of things that people need, who will be producing wealth and trading tit for tat. That is how I believe the workers will be paid and supplies purchsed. And little by little, The Coin of the Realm will emerge. Freely given and freely taken.
"The only domestic beneficiaries from the existence of anonymity-providing currency are the criminal fraternity: those engaged in tax evasion and money laundering, and those wishing to store the proceeds from crime and the means to commit further crimes. Large denomination bank notes are an especially scandalous subsidy to criminal activity and to the grey and black economies. There is no economic justification for $50 and $100 bank notes, let alone for the 200 and 500 bank notes issued by the ECB".
There it is in a nut shell boys and girls! If we leave the Establishment, Valuation, and Control of "money" to ANYTHING except the Free Market we are doomed to the chains of tyranny these folks have already forged for us.
Talk about A Moratorium on Brains. If we do that it will be a Crematorium of Brains!
Thanks for your observations. Very thought provoking!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.