But that's all irrelevant for the Annenberg site. Their COLB would have to be created and printed, then embossed and folded, then photographed. That is all possible, but someone would have to do it and a bunch of Annenberg people would have to trust that person and go along with it. Ignoring the Annenberg site to focus on the low res possible photoshop on the Fight the Smears site is just a distraction.
Your wording sounded like a confirmation of forgery to me. If I had a document that was forged on my own site and you agreed; I have no idea how you could be so sure that the same document on a 3rd party site would be legit.