[Mr. Silverback]

Actually, the only insulting thing I've said was "moronic," and I didn't direct that at a specific person but at the idea that "FDR knew."

Please don't bother trying to make me feel guilty for thinking these theories are loopy...it's a waste of your time.

[BroJoeK]

"Please don't bother trying to make me feel guilty for thinking these theories are loopy...it's a waste of your time."

Sorry, but I have no idea what you mean by "these theories."

The fact is, there are huge volumes of data showing both what FDR said, and what he knew at the time.

And, as I said on my first post (see #37), none of this data "proves" that Roosevelt knew precisely what was going to happen on December 7, 1941.

But it does definitely suggest that Roosevelt, Marshall & all, knew a lot more than was contained in the "war warning" sent to Kimmel & Short.

The reason I recommend The Pearl Harbor Myth is because, perhaps uniquely among such books, the author is sympatheticly pro-Roosevelt.

Nor does the author EVER pretend that the data says more than it does. So, I'll say again, I think it could open your eyes, and maybe even change your mind.