Standard palaeo hostility (the USA being the "new Israel" in the Rushdoonian "reconstructionist" worldview). Baldwin used to be with Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority but the Birchites got to him and he turned against Israel.
Keyes was rejected because he is pro-Israel, and the CP honchos regard the "Zionists" as the "secret power" behind the "new world order."
Chuck Baldwin is the founder and pastor of Crossroads Baptist Church. I took this from their website. I couldn’t find anything about him being anti Israel. Where did you get your information about his anti Israel views? I also checked out JBS.org and could find nothing there about Israel.
“Some of the choice spiritual and political leaders of the nation have spoken in this pulpit including the late Dr. Jerry Falwell, Pat Buchanan, former Alabama Supreme Court Chief Justice Roy Moore, and former Ambassador Alan Keyes.”
They fashion themselves as the last holdout of true conservatism, but in reality, they are a hideout for anti-Israel, isolationist paleocons who would be perfectly comfortable in the 1930s.
Keyes didn't represent their foreign policy views at all and never had a chance.
Conservatism is in the ICU at present...