This has been fun and rather addictive. Geeez, we will be talking up until Idol at this rate! Seems like we agree on a lot and both have good points. GMTA!
I liked some Carly Simon songs but I can see what you mean about not connecting with Brooke because her being a Carly Simon type. After all, I am a hard rocker but like some lighter stuff. Brooke is very talented and could be in the top 3 or 4.
One more guy - Michael the dude from down under. When he sings Queen he is amazing. Would love to hear him sing INXS. At other times, he isn’t that good. How can you sing Queen (Freddie Mercury) one of the most unique and amazing voices and not be able to pull off other songs? Go figure.
The next few weeks will really be interesting. Thank you. This has been entertaining. Never thought I would be on Free Republic chatting about American Idol!
Once again, it’s as if we’re of a same mind. I agree with you. I am generally not a rocker. I do like the guy with the hair problem though. Last night’s performance was brilliant.
You take care.