[CommerceComet]

The Holey Kore-an says that Abraham, Isaac, Noah, Adam, Jesus and others were ALL Muslimss. And the Holey K can not be wrong. There must’ve been some time-slip continuum where the Prophet went back in time and taught these people to be good M’s.

Do they say that Melchizedek was a Muslim? Then they could argue (with absolutely no evidence, however) that he converted Abraham in their meeting. Of course, that would mean that there were Muslim prophets before Mohammad.

[Cronos]

Of course, that would mean that there were Muslim prophets before Mohammad

Ok, seriously, that is EXACTLY what Muslims say -- they say that Abraham, Jesus etc. were all Muslim prophets and Muslims and that Mohammed was the last. They also allege that Islam was the original religion and everyone else fell away from it. Hence, they call conversions to islam, revision, not conversion, arguing that you are reverting back to the original religion.