Maybe, maybe not. See post 206. You seem concerned that people aren't seeing things from the LEO's point of view. If I'm not mistaken, the police consider someone making seemingly contradictory statements reasonable cause for suspicion.
I don’t see your point. Giving seemingly contradictory statements is a well-recognized cause for suspicion. Give me a “fer instance”. Oh yeah, I know some police officers are LEOs, but my brother-in-law is an AQUARIUS.