I don’t see your point. Giving seemingly contradictory statements is a well-recognized cause for suspicion. Give me a “fer instance”. Oh yeah, I know some police officers are LEOs, but my brother-in-law is an AQUARIUS.
You’ve made seemingly contradictory statement, so now I’m suspicious. You’ve also refused to respond to a direct question. I don’t see that as being any less suspicious than refusing to consent to a search, which also makes me suspicious. At this point I really don’t have much reason to believe anything you say, and probable cause to disbelieve it.