Posted on 07/06/2007 7:57:19 PM PDT by libertarianPA
FRIDAY, July 6 (HealthDay News) -- Soaring U.S. medical costs are causing many Americans to take to the skies on "medical tourism" junkets, looking for high-quality yet low-priced health care at foreign clinics.
In many cases, patients get exactly what they are looking for, but experts also warn that the booming industry does have some risks.
"My own advice would be to look carefully at the accreditation of the hospital and consider the nature of the procedure. Are you sure it is the procedure you need? And is it done well at the place you are going?" said Dr. Ann Marie Kimball, a professor of epidemiology and health services at the University of Washington School of Public Health, in Seattle.
The surge in medical tourism over the past decade is being driven by rising U.S. health-care costs and growing numbers of uninsured or under-insured Americans, said Josef Woodman, the author of a guidebook on the topic called Patients Beyond Borders.
Almost 45 million Americans, or slightly more than 15 percent of the population, are currently uninsured, according to U.S. Census Bureau statistics from 2005, the latest available.
Woodman estimated that more than 150,000 Americans traveled abroad for health care in 2006. The number is projected to double in 2007, he said.
"That 150,000 number is conservative," he said. "Some experts say 400,000." Among the top destinations: Southeast Asia and Mexico, with many other countries, such as Costa Rica, expected to be the next popular destinations for medical care.
Medical tourism companies, in collaboration with special "health travel agents," have sprung up across the country, and some insurance plans are participating in these endeavors, as well.
In California, for instance, Salud con Health Net, a program of Health Net of California, provides access to health care for their insured Latino participants for services conducted across the border in Mexico. And BlueCross/BlueShield of South Carolina and BlueChoice HealthPlan of South Carolina now offer medical care at Bumrungrad International Hospital in Bangkok, Thailand, among treatment options. Bumrungrad treats more than 400,000 international patients every year.
The price savings on cross-border medical care can be dramatic. For example, one commercial medical tourism Web site (www.medicaltourism.com) estimates that a heart bypass in the United States costs $130,000, but just $10,000 in India and $11,000 in Thailand. A hip replacement in the United States would cost $43,000 but just $12,000 in Thailand or Singapore. Hysterectomy costs are about $20,000 here but $3,000 in India.
The medical tourism companies that have sprung up can help travelers find the hospital that provides the procedure or care they need. A growing number of overseas hospitals are accredited under the Joint Commission International, the international arm of the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organization (JCAHO), which accredits U.S. hospitals and other facilities.
As the practice has become more common, medical tourism has evolved, Woodman said. While the practice used to be associated with vacations -- get your facelift, sit on the beach -- and sometimes still is, for most procedures, he recommended separating the surgery from the vacation.
"Even after a minor surgery, there can be swelling," Woodman said. "Most doctors will advise you to stay out of the sun after surgery."
"It's not a 'fun in the sun' gimmick," he added. "People are going overseas and getting serious surgeries."
Medical tourism isn't without some concerns, of course. Experts in the United States worry that consumers might end up getting substandard care i f they don't choose their hospital and physician carefully.
The American Society of Plastic Surgeons has issued a briefing paper on the subject, cautioning potential patients that "it may be difficult to assess the training and credentials of surgeons outside of the United States." The ASPS also stressed that typical vacation activities -- which are sometimes marketed as part of a surgery trip -- should be avoided to allow for proper healing and reduce the risk of complications.
Even when patients select and book medical care abroad through a health travel agent, they must remain critical, informed health-care consumers, Woodman said.
The main thing a patient needs to do, he said, is check out the accreditation of the hospital and the credentials of the surgeon.
Spread of disease is another potential concern, said Kimball, who is also director of the APEC Asia Pacific Emerging Infectious Disease Network and author of Risky Trade: Infectious Disease in the Era of Global Trade.
"Medical tourism is obviously a route for pathogen spread," Kimball said, noting that different hospitals in different regions may have different types of flora. "The extent to which it's a problem versus a theoretical concern is as yet not known," she said. "I can't issue a blank 'go' or 'don't go,'" she added.
Kimball's advice: Look carefully at the accreditation of the hospital concerned and do your homework before you board the plane. "Check out the number of surgeries done, the success rates," Woodman added. It's also key to ask the surgeon you talk to if he or she will perform the operation, not an assistant.
Kimball said she urges potential medical tourists to talk it over with their own physician. As the concept and the practice of medical tourism has evolved, she said, a physician is not likely to automatically rule out the idea.
She also doesn't report on the thousands of foreigners who come here for immediate medical care every year because they're tired of waiting on lists in their own countries.
Surgical supplies and drugs provided by China, LOL.
I’d certainly consider retaining some 26 year old “brilliant neurosurgeon” working for England’s National Health Service.
The cost for the travel abroad is a drop in the bucket compared to the savings encountered for the operation.
This is no BS. Sixty Minutes featured this last year.
Quality healthcare costs money. Geta job with benefits and pay for it. Or bitch about it and trust some mexican quack to do surgery on you.
This whole "healthcare crisis" is becoming tiresome and is almost reaching to crescendo of Global Warming..
Going to a hospital located in a Second or Third World country is crazy.....*crazy* I tell you.
>>>If the author actually believes any of the BS she wrote...
Going off shore for medical procedures is indeed a growth market, particularly for expensive testing.
But there are some cautions: doctors in Asia are not used to the larger and less sensitive Caucasian body type. Getting an Asian to pull out deeply rooted white-man or black-man’s teeth could be a problem. And, thus there might also be problems on judging the amounts of anaesthetics. Lower ethics overseas is often offset by out-of-control profit motives of doctors or drowning paperwork and other government regulations here in the U.S. (not reimbursing tests, and this shuts out searching for causes, for example).
Lots of people from Californistan travel (or used to) to Mexico for alternative dentistry. Britons now regularly travel to India for emergency heart operations, rather than wait around and die waiting in London.
The best deal on health travel, to my mind, focuses on reducing the cost of annual testing, and the cost of recovery (high labor). The operations are more safely done in the U.S.
The quality of nursing care (as opposed to medical doctors) may be much higher overseas. For example, many U.S. nurses can’t find the magic spot to take blood samples. Those overseas poke around much less.
1. Not everyone can luck out and get a job with benefits. When you get older, the cost of health insurance skyrockets. Numerous people cannot take early retirement because health insurance for a married couple in their early sixties costs as much as 18K annually. If you have a condition, you can’t even get insurance.
2. There are a handful of foreign hospitals which meet American standards and have JCI accredition.
Check out:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=paNRv-—Adw
Recently had some teeth work done in Mexico at very reasonable cost, very clean and professional, highly recommend.
No doubt you have researched them all including Bumrungrad in Bangkok with it's many US board certified specialists.
That one impressed me so much, I bought stock in it.
While I will not disagree with the numbers quoted in your referenced video, you must remember that it only focuses on the free ride the young and irresponsible is getting. It does not say one thing about the old and responsible. It did not say a word about how much health insurance costs them.
Regarding the second video, I agree that socialized medicine, as practiced elsewhere, is not the answer. As I see it, the only way around our high costs is a Bumrungrad type solution.
Hey the insurance companies and doctors are telling us how great the free market is in healthcare. Here is people looking at costs and options and deciding for themselves and paying completely on their own.
Btw my idea for the auto companies retiree healthcare costs was to do all the major procedures outside of the US. A lot of retired workers I think would actually be happy to get a paid for vacation to Thailand or India. Thailand is a long journey, but it looks like they have lots of well trained people.
Some insurance companies are beginning to offer totally free operations (no deductables or copays) if you go out of the country for the operation.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.