Posted on 03/26/2007 3:27:31 PM PDT by paltz
Count me in on that one. Plus I am registered on the Bone Marrow Donation list
I can think of one other possible reason:
4) Sister has contracted an illness (possibly sexually transmitted) which she doesn't want to spread to her brother, and is too embarrassed to tell him about.
Talk about cheapening the language, and the qualities that make us human.
Hard to tell who is the more selfish here. Seriously.
The lifesaving act of donation is, or should be, one of love, not of intimidation, even among strangers; never mind family.
I shall say no more than that, not knowing more specifics.
There would be no concerns for her if she was a despicable mentally ill narcissist or psychopath, perhaps. The fact that she is reveling in her hateful attitude rather than feeling deeply ashamed for playing her evil games tells what sort of worthless human being she herself is, IMO.
It wasn't because of ill feelings toward each other. The sister just didn't want to go through the process even though she was tested and was a perfect match.
My husband has terminal cancer, his brothers would go to any lengths to save him.
That's great (and I mean that). But I think you are not in the majority.
Anyway, my big problem with the donor system is that I don't want to help a silly rationing system when a free market would free up millions of organs. For example, the organs are worth A LOT of money. Let's say my organs are worth 500K. There is a certain probability that I will die in a manner such that my organs become useful to someone else. Discount back 25 years, and an insurance company or someone else ought to be able to pay me 10K or so for the rights to my organs if I die. I would do that. So would millions of others who right now have not filled out their donor cards.
The reason this is not done is two-fold. One, the communal types don't like people making money, and the organ bit makes their rhetoric more powerful. 2nd, and most important, right now the doctors and everyone else involved gets your multi-hundred-thousands dollar input into their multi-hunderd-thousand dollar operations for free. They'd hate to have to pay for the damned thing.
It is simply economic fact: Price controls result in shortages. The price on organs is set at zero, therefore, there is a massive shortage. There is nothing unique about this product compared to all the other attempts that socialists have attempt price controls. They ALWAYS result in shortages. In this case, people die as a result.
Huh.
Been thinking about this for a few minutes, just to make sure, but I can't think of one. Honestly.
In fact, I can't think of a single person I know that I wouldn't do it for.
Now, I can think of a lot of people I don't like hanging around with, but I'd still probably give them whatever they needed.
Weird. But I'll keep trying.
What do you mean "he has nothing to lose?" He may shortly be meeting his Maker. Would you want to go to judgment with such a sin on your soul? You know there really will be a reckoning some day when we all stand before the Judge of Heaven and Earth and account for our actions.
Free Republic is nothing if not predictable.
Yep.
The choice of language and phrasing from the recipient I characterize as equally inhuman.
If one successfully can intimidate another this way, it would be just a short step until we reach the bottom of that slippery slope.
Yep.
Also it is what it is. There is no time to waste being angry and bitter with the sister.
What could he have possibly done to justify her inhumane attitude? You're going to extreme speculative lengths to justify her vengeful taunting and obvious unfeeling selfishness for no known reason.
From the looks of sis, she can keep her bone marrow!
In some areas of the world today where high technology and weird religions coexist, it is still a prized gift.
He probably doesn't approve that she is a lesbian.
However, my solution would be to limit or ban the donation of organs to people that refuse to sign a Donor Card.
ROFLMAO....I put black ink on sisters old black rotary telephone receiver...The Legend of Black Ear was born....
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.