I would hope that either Justice Ginsburg or Justice Stevens are gone and replaced by a new Bush appointee before that happens. Right now, I worry about the outcome of that SC case if Justice Kennedy is the "swing" vote. If Bush makes a new appointment -- confirmed by the Senate or as a recess appointment -- in the mold of Alito and Roberts, I would not worry about the outcome of that case.
John / Billybob
the SC should have taken the Emerson case a year ago, to eliminate the conflict among the Circuit Courts