I thought the T-shirt guy was good -- but slightly miscast alongside the two news anchors. There was a "synch" problem, IMO. Some parts of their exchanges were wickedly good and well delivered.
I watched our "TIVO" of the show and I have to agree -- the T-Shirt guy was fine and the whole show was very good. And the people who complain about a laugh track -- I'm pretty sure this was done in front of a relatively small live audience (around 200 people maybe?). Didn't sound like a laugh track to me -- except you're not used to hearing people laugh at politically incorrect jokes or jokes aimed at leftist, liberal "progressive" slime-balls! That was the best part! And Rush's intro was terrific.