Replies

DuncanWaring wrote: "That (good police work) certainly worked well with Mohammad Atta and his Merrie Band, didn't it?"

No, it didn't. But, good police work is what we need to take down the violent Muslims in the US. What you are advocating (the identification and incarceration of millions of law-abiding citizens solely for their religious affiliation) is illegal, immoral, counterproductive, and impractical. If you can't see that, I'm wasting my time even discussing it.

And to the other FReeper who mentioned our incarceration of hundreds of thousands of Japanese in WWII--that was reprehensible, too. Those poor Japanese were wrongly held for something they had absolutely no control over--their ethnic heritage.

"But, good police work is what we need to take down the violent Muslims in the US. "

Yeah. Catch them AFTER THE FACT. Real helpful.

"Those poor Japanese were wrongly held for something they had absolutely no control over--their ethnic heritage."

"What you are advocating (the identification and incarceration of millions of law-abiding citizens solely for their religious affiliation) is illegal, immoral, counterproductive, and impractical. If you can't see that, I'm wasting my time even discussing it."

It is none of those things. Allegiance to Islam is sedition in a time of war. Islam is NOT a religion. It is a hostile political system. We had no trouble shutting down hostile Nazi and Japanese "patriotic" organizations during World War II. This is no different.

Oh, BS. Those Issei were interned based on actionable intelligence AND the efforts Imperial Japan had expended to keep them loyal to the Emperor.

Your PC attitudes will not get you very far. Why don't you try actually reading the history and not just depend on what the MSM spoon-feeds you.