He would look the same dark color as the Jews in Israel today, he would not look like a Zulu IMO.
That said, makes no difference what color he was.
Why on Earth would you think that? The Jewish population in Israel today is an admixture of every population the Jews blended into in the centuries when they lacked a homeland. You have Sephardic Jews who mingled with the Spanish and Portuguese, Ashkenazic Jews who were in Central Europe, and prominent figures like Natan Sharansky, whose first name as Anatoly before he escaped the USSR.
That said, makes no difference what color he was.
True. So if it wasn't a distortion to make him look like Ted Nugent, it's also not a distortion to make him look like Bob Marley.