The problem is that none of the 9-11 attackers had these "telltale factors". They were not bearded, skullcap wearing, robed folks. None of them dressed as conservative Muslims. They were dressed like regular Americans living regular lives.
And that is why we shouldn't screen and profile Muslims? What a logic!
Security professionals had lifted these procedures to the state of art; there are much more factors they take into consideration that the dress code.
While you may not think there is a need to profile, I do, and it won't stop me from applying that profiling while I'm traveling and moving around.... to each his own, I guess.