Posted on 08/07/2006 6:30:32 AM PDT by spartagroup
Excellent.
Great satire on how the current Hatriotics in charge of our MSM would have reported on WWII,
It didn't just seem to be. It was indiscriminate.
Both the Americans and (especially) the British used an area bombardment strategy in which cities were attacked intentionally, with the explicit goal of killing as many civilians as possible.
This was supposed to "break the German will to resist."
Didn't work.
'Both the Americans and (especially) the British used an area bombardment strategy in which cities were attacked intentionally, with the explicit goal of killing as many civilians as possible.
This was supposed to "break the German will to resist."
Didn't work.'
That's because the bombs were too small. When the US targeted Hiroshima and Nagasaki with the explicit goal of killing as many civillians as possible, only with much bigger bombs, it worked very well. . . . .
The military effect of The Bombs were almost entirely on morale and psychology. The actual destruction and deaths they caused could have been (and were being) duplicated by firestorm raids on the Japanese cities. More people died in the firestorm raid on Tokyo than in either Hiroshima or Nagasaki.
However, the psychological impact of a single plane dropping a single bomb and destroying an entire city must have been immense.
We won didn't we? Every dead German was one less to pick up a gun. To say that the resources Germans expended defending their cities and the fighter pilots they sacrificed in a hopeless effort did not degrade their ability to wage war is silly. We had complete air supremacy by D-Day. That didn't just happen. Germany was waging their second war in a generation. They needed to be defeated utterly.
Didn't work when Hitler tried it on the British either.
Way I see it, the British were just delivering some payback with Dresden and such.
Nope We're still fighting them.
Every dead German was one less to pick up a gun.
True. Except that since most German men were off in the military, those affected by the area bombing were primarily civilians, mostly women and children.
But it was disproportionate payback. Can't have that.
The Activism sidebar is reserved for Activism, protests, news and business of Free Republic Chapters.
Not this.
Please read the following for FR's posting rules for further guidelines.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1611173/posts
Thanks,
Most of the people were in bomb shelters. I have to believe a lot of them died of asphyxiation. Now we have the Massive Ordinance Air Burst (MOAB) and other fuel-air ordinance to do it much more easier.
Yes, it did, we just did not see the "benifits" until after the shooting stopped. The Germans were beaten down and did not have the will or where-with-all to resist occupation.
Area bombing was supposed to make the Germans stop fighting. It didn't do that.
The invasion and conquest of Germany by the Allied and Red Armies did accomplish it.
Area bombing helped to some extent, but its contribution to Nazi defeat was not even close to being in proportion to its cost in dollars and in flight crew and civilian deaths.
PAYBACK is a BITCH!
poseur
Webster's Main Entry: po·seur
Function: noun
Etymology: French
Date: 1872
- a person who pretends to be what he or she is not : an affected or insincere person
Thank you!
It worked just fine! Thousands fewer German/Nazi sympathizers.
You'd think people would learn from history- or just the laws of cause and effect!
Start sh*t, GET sh*it.
Today Muslims =Nazis.
There were NO 'good Nazis' then. It would have been ludicrous-and treasonous- to suggest that only the SS were 'bad' Nazis, and that Nazism inherently bad.
Only the names have changed now.
If you believe in something inherently evil, you are evil.
It's so simple no one wants to face it.
Maybe indescriminate, but not innacurate.
As LT Beldon Cooper in his book "Deathtraps" on his days in WWII in Army Ordinance. His account of entering Cologne (after knocking out a stubborn Panther tank, with a brand new Pershing tank) said that all of the city was rubble with the exception of the famous Koln Cathedral, and the Ford Motor Company factory...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.