I just found out that the first Jay (Jay Traynor) is still alive and has become a member of the Tokens. Jay Seigel is the only original member of the Tokens, but he is the lead singer on all of the Token's hits.
Jay Traynor was the original Jay of Jay and the Americans, but he only appears on a few songs. "She Cried" was the only hit with Traynor as the lead. Shortly after, the group had a falling out, Traynor left and was replaced by Jay Black. I have an album of Jay and the Americans that has a cover version of Gene Pitney's "24 hours from Tulsa".
How's that for a Rock and Roll lesson?
Wasn't Donald Fagen (Steely Dan) the keyboardist for J&A?
Thanks for that excellent research. Both Jay's are alive and singing well!
Better do a little more "homework" before you post another "Rock 'n' Roll History Lesson" - Phil Margo and Mitch Margo are alive and (very) well, thus deeming Jay Seigel not the "only original Token" - How do I know this? Because when in the late 80's promoters were wondering where the group has been, I helped put it back together with Mitch & Phil (on the West Coast), and to this day still perform with them as a Token AND also with Jay for certain east coast and corporate dates-we have "reunited" on more than a few occasion, to boot.
OK - time for recess and dance to "The Lion Sleeps Tonight"
Jayles1015@aol.com