Posted on 04/03/2006 10:02:15 AM PDT by Abathar
INDIANAPOLIS -- A school principal in Indianapolis suspended an eighth-grader for 10 days and recommended he be expelled for carrying a pocket knife, even though the boy said he had forgotten the weapon was in his coat pocket and turned it over to school officials as soon as he entered the building.
An expulsion hearing has been scheduled for April 10.
Elliot Voge, 14, told Stoneybrook Middle School principal Jimmy Meadows he forgot that he had left the Swiss Army knife in his pocket after using it to whittle wood last month. The next day, just after he was dropped off at school by a classmate's mother, he said he discovered the knife in his coat and immediately went to the office.
Nevertheless, Meadows suspended him and recommended expulsion. The action stunned the boy's parents, who hired a lawyer to represent him at the hearing next week.
your not getting to much support on this one....
Hurling obscene epithets at her isn't going to help.
The crux of the matter, as you indicate in your last sentence, is that the student proactively did something to avoid continuing to break the rules. In recognizing that having the knife was against the rules, and then by trying to turn it in, the boy did right (I'm not talking about the rule itself, BTW).
No good deed...
Well knives can be mighty handy tools, and Swiss Army knives, with all the tweezers, toothpicks, screwdrivers, etc, even more so. Since girls often carry purses (my younger one did and does not, and she's 26 and a PhD student) and so could easily carry the larger versions of the Swiss Army Knife. And if some scum bag gets a bit too familiar and doesn't take "NO" for an answer, well the tool could be put to good use then as well.
Some schools have, or had, rifle and shotgun teams, so then there would be a reason to take one of those to school as well.
I just don't care either way about you or your feelings towards me. I would ask that you follow the accepted rules of posting as this is JimRob's place -- not yours or mine.
I agree. A "no tolerance" policy is not threatened by permitting students who have accidentally brought a "weapon" to school to turn it in. If the story is accurate, the principal's position is stupid because its creating an incentive for students to hide weapons.
Maybe you should tell the AP and give detention...
Yea, and I'm sure they obey the rules about not taking knives into the school. Riight.
I detect an NEA Lib
"Some schools have, or had, rifle and shotgun teams, so then there would be a reason to take one of those to school as well."
I spent Saturday with 400 high school and Junior High school kids..all armed!!!!!
Not one person was hurt..but a lot of pigeons where broken (clay!!!)
These where trap teams...proof..guns don't kill people..people kill people...!!!
I think it's a completely stupid policy. I think the people who instituted it are whiny morons. I won't say what I think of the people who enforce it.
That stated, one of my students did bring in a knife (by accident) a few months ago.
**GASP** Oh! The Horror!
I guess it's the accidental part ... I'm not sure I'd trust a fellow who didn't know he had a knife in his front pocket.
I brought my knife to school quite deliberately, every day. My teachers would occasionally ask for help opening boxes and the like.
Just because we disagree on one part of one issue does not demonize me or you. Since when do all conservatives have to be lock-step agreement or be accused of being liberal?
Then you may have been with my nephew, who shoots for the team affiliated with North Star, IIRC. It's his second year and last year he did very well in the state meet at Doniphan. Placed just out of the top 10 after the shoot off. Competed with his grandfather's old JC Higgens, but has a new gun this year.
He was wearing his older brother's jacket.
They are aligned with the school districts
who pass out condoms so 3rd graders and
expel kindergartners for sexual harrassment.
Way to go mindless idiots!!!!
Stupid...no common sense. What do you expect from liberal demotrash whose main goal in life is to usurp a parents rights in addition to continously ripping the emotion and common sense out of children?
They want to create robotic humans who don't think and feel, especially who don't think and feel what THEY are doing and taking away from the individual. The end result is tolerance for every imaginable abomination on earth...a liberal pigs dream!!!
As I posted earlier, back in the olden days when I was in school, just about everyone carried a pocket knife. I got in a fair number of fights growing up. No one ever pulled their pocket knife to use as a weapon. The only time I was ever stabbed was an accident and it was by a kid with a pencil.
A pocket knife is not a weapon. It is a tool. Like most tools, it can be used as a weapon. A sharpened pencil or a pair of scissors would make a better weapon though.
You better hope JimRob does not have a zero-tolerance policy.
And you never stabbed anyone? How did you control yourself?
This kid had the knife in the pocket of his heavy coat.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.