Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Senator Bedfellow
Have we settled on a critique, then? Abandoning Hoyle just like that?

Yeah "we" were waiting on you. Finally you produced something that might bring your sequence "homologs such as the protamines may well have served some entirely different function before doing what histones do now. A minor change to that homolog, and presto - histones" out of the fiction category.

Now you mention protamines having a minor change and presto a histone.

The accession numbers you gave are not protamines but contain protamine-like sequences and are of histone domains. So what you evidently are saying is that the protamine with a minor change became .... well let's look at the sequences.

1 mpspsrksrs rsrsrskspk rspakkarkt pkkpraaggv kkpstlsmiv aaitamknrk
61 gssvqairky ilannkgint shlgsamkla fakglksgvl vrpktsagas gatgsfrvgk
121 apaspkkakk akspkkkssk nksnnakakk sprkkaavkk stkskakkpk spkkkaakkt
181 arkspkkkar kspkkkaakk skk

akakksprkk aavkkstksk akkpkspkkk aakktarksp kkkarkspkk kaakkskk Q05831(Protamine-like protein PHI-3)

1 aggvkkpttl smivaaitam knrkgssvqa irkyilannk gintshlgsa mklafakglk
61 sgvlvrlkts agasgatgsf rvgkapaspk kakkakspkk ksskksknks nnakakkspk
121 kkadsn

akakkspkkk adsn Q86QI0(Protamine-like OS3)

1 mpspsrksrs rsrsrskspk rspakkarkt pkkpraagga kkpttlsmiv aaitamknrk
61 gssvqairky ilannkgint shlgsamkla fakglksgvl vrpktsagas gatgsfrvgk
121 apaspkkakk akspkkkssk ksknksnnak akkspkkkad sngiryqayr yrrprggary
181 pfryqayryr rprggpgtqf al

1 akakkspkkk adsngiryqa yryrrprgga rypfryqayr yrrprggpgt qfal Q86QH9(Protamine-like OS3)

Those small parts are protamine-like. The rest of the sequence for each is histone-like. So essentially what you are saying is that the small part with a minor change, "presto", becomes the whole thing. Nope, that is still in the category of fiction. A minor change is considered somewhat less than adding 100% of something.

287 posted on 01/29/2006 8:52:07 PM PST by AndrewC (Darwinian logic -- It is just-so if it is just-so)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 286 | View Replies ]


To: AndrewC
...protamine-like sequences and are of histone domains.

My point exactly. Protamines and histones are obviously related, as you can see from the sequence fragments here. In addition, we know that protamines can serve as functional alternatives to histones - Nature, 403, 261-263(2000). Or are you still chasing poor Fred and his absolute, 100%, no-way-in-hell impossibility theory?

Sorry, Hoyle loses.

288 posted on 01/29/2006 9:17:44 PM PST by Senator Bedfellow
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 287 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson