The Dover decision was an error of judgment and will eventually be overturned, at least if we ever get jurists who know what the Constitution means.
The decision was correct, and in accordance with the law.
And, in addition, the time to appeal the Kitzmiller v. Dover decision expired yesterday, by my estimation. Since no appeal was taken, the decision by Judge Jones is now final and unappealable. (PH: I thought you'd find it noteworthy.)