[JNL]

Oh goody another ID / EVO thread, this time my money is on the ID ers winning this one but later in the afternoon the EVO's will win the next thread.

Even though I'm a big critic of the ID movement I am now leaning towards the ID argument. It has been decisively proven time and time in these threads that a believer in ID can never evolve into a supporter of Darwin.

Personally that settles it for me.

[moog]

Oh goody another ID / EVO thread

I come here for the entertainment too. I can't resist it sometimes. This time I got a little too involved in the "discussion" (if you can call my comments being a discussion:).

[Ichneumon]

It has been decisively proven time and time in these threads that a believer in ID can never evolve into a supporter of Darwin.

Actually, the talk.origins newsgroup -- a Usenet discussion forum dedicated to this topic -- maintains a lengthy list of people who have admitted to having switched from being a creationist to an evolutionist as a result of the discussions on that forum, or from other such debates.

Last time I checked, they couldn't find a single person who personally claimed to have been "converted" in the other direction.