Well if by "libertarian conservative" the poster meant one that is in favor of limited government; I didn't know that such a creature existed anymore.
i don't presume to speak for Appypappy, who, if i am not mistaken, was the one that made the original comment, but my take is that those who know what an evangelical christian worldview means are more likely to give this woman the benefit of the doubt. others, for whom religion is not a concern, are more likely to be opposed to it. and those who are bushbashers are going to hate whomever he picks.