[shezza]

Webster: If there is a conflict, it's up to the court to make the decision. We should err on the side of life. (shezza's question: does this leave it again up to the discretion of the judge? Greer said he found "clear and compelling evidence" to believe Michael and Scott and Joan's testimony and completely disregard testimony to the contrary. That makes the threshhold a variable, which can still be exploited.)

[Abby4116]

Greer said he found "clear and compelling evidence" to believe Michael and Scott and Joan's testimony and completely disregard testimony to the contrary. That makes the threshhold a variable, which can still be exploited.)

But the contrary evidence was not admitted because of an ERROR THAT THE JUDGE MADE about what year Karen Quinlan DIED, not the year that she had the respirator removed.

[LegalEagle61]

Webster: If there is a conflict, it's up to the court to make the decision. We should err on the side of life. (shezza's question: does this leave it again up to the discretion of the judge? Greer said he found "clear and compelling evidence" to believe Michael and Scott and Joan's testimony and completely disregard testimony to the contrary. That makes the threshhold a variable, which can still be exploited.)


I know, I felt that way too

[Krodg]

I don't understand how this will help Terri.