Legalistic crap, eh? Well, then, we can agree to disagree.
I guess so, unless you can justify in some meaningful way why the court can make such a decision. Your post only said they could weigh the evidence to render a decision regarding guardianship. It did not say what evidence was weighed and how these judges arrived at their decision, so for the layman, your answer falls way short of the mark of explaining their action. And you expect others to simply agree?