Posted on 02/25/2005 10:22:46 PM PST by NormsRevenge
TORONTO - Jewish activists Friday hailed a court ruling that allows Canada to deport German Holocaust denier Ernst Zundel to face prosecution at home.
Zundel, author of "The Hitler We Loved and Why," has been held in a Toronto jail for two years while authorities determined whether he posed a security risk to Canadian society.
Federal Court Justice Pierre Blais said Zundel's activities were not only a threat to national security, "but also a threat to the international community of nations."
Zundel, a leading proponent of white supremacy, claims the Holocaust never happened.
In his 63-page decision released in Ottawa on Thursday, Blais called Zundel a racist hypocrite and said his Toronto home was a "revolving door" for some of the world's most notorious white supremacists who have promoted violence and hatred against Jews and minorities.
"It is time for Zundel's plane to take off. This should mark a closure to the tireless efforts of many to bring Zundel to justice," said Frank Dimant, executive vice president of B'nai Brith of Canada.
B'nai Brith and other Jewish organizations in Canada and the United States have for decades followed Zundel's activities and intervened in the legal proceedings against him.
"The impact of Zundel's removal from Canada is significant," said Len Rudner, national director of community relations for the Canadian Jewish Congress. "It's an indictment of hatred, an indictment of violence."
Zundel faces prosecution in Germany for his neo-Nazi and Holocaust-denying activities. Since the late 1970s he has operated Samisdat Publishing, one of the leading distributors of Nazi propaganda and since 1995 has been a key content provider for a Web site dedicated to Holocaust denial, according to the the Anti-Defamation League.
German authorities told the Canadian Press on Friday that Zundel would be picked up and arrested as soon as he arrived back in his homeland.
Zundel's lawyer Peter Lindsay said in statement that Zundel would not appeal and expected to be deported as early as next Tuesday.
"Probably no one cares because Mr. Ernst Zundel is notorious and reviled," Lindsay said. "The powerful and the popular do not need to rely on the fairness of our legal system. The marginalized and the reviled do. Our system has failed Mr. Zundel."
Zundel spokesman Mark Weber said Zundel was being persecuted for his personal beliefs.
"The government case is based on pretext, innuendo," Weber said by phone. "The judge cites no concrete basis that he is a threat to national security. He merely points out that Zundel met with people who, arguably, might be a threat to national security. That's not a crime. It's a dangerous precedent and it's a dangerous blow against freedom for Canadians."
Born in Germany in 1939, Zundel emigrated to Canada in 1958 and lived in Toronto and Montreal until 2001. Canadian officials rejected his attempts to obtain Canadian citizenship in 1966 and 1994. He moved to Pigeon Forge, Tenn., until he was deported back to Canada in 2003 for alleged immigration violations.
Zundel claimed in court that he is a peaceful man who has no criminal record or charges against him in Canada. Lindsay, his attorney, challenged the constitutionality of the security certificate review process, saying it violates his client's right to free speech and association.
The Canadian security certificate law, passed after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in the United States, allows the government to hold terrorism suspects without charge, based on secret evidence that does not have to be disclosed to a suspect's defense.
Alan Borovoy, general counsel for the Canadian Civil Liberties Association said intelligence authorities may know of criminal offenses by Zundel, which cannot be disclosed for reasons of national security, but the detainment without charge or public evidence smacks of injustice.
"Zundel, I have no difficulty saying, is a nasty, nasty character and everything I'm saying is without the slightest sympathy for him," Borovoy said. "But the process in itself is unfair."
_____
On the Net:
Web site for followers of Zundel: www.zundelsite.org
Text of ruling: www.fct-cf.gc.ca/bulletins
Maybe you want to decry the lack of "freedom" here, and move on....
We are talking about Canada here. The US is not Canada. In the US, we do not need to deny jokers like this guy his right to speak (although we would certainly throw his ass in jail if his speech led to violence). We just laugh at them.
Veronica, how can I stop beating my wife, when I have never beaten her?
Someone was kind enough to explain this to me.
This has nothing to do with freedom of speech. This guy was not a Canadian citizen. He was a German citizen. The Canadians have every right to deport an undesirable alien. So do we (the US) and I would hope that we would deport such a person ourselves.
We can argue that the Canadians may or may not be consistent in who they think is an undesirable. But let's agree that they were right this time and send this slime-ball packing.
We did. I think he lived here a couple of years. The legal proceedings deporting him back to Canada took a few weeks, but in fairness he has a decades long history in Canada from which to make a case to be allowed to stay.
---Does Canada have a Bill of Rights?---
No and most countries don't, something it might be helpful to have emphasized in civics class once in awhile. I believe that in Canada as in Great Britain you have the right to beg your member of parliment for help and the right to hope that "traditional privilages" are on your side.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.