I think players should be comfortable, with gloves or without doesn't matter to me. I think the problem comes in when a players only wears gloves in cold weather, there's an adjustment period that contains bad play, it should be a commitment to wear them or don't year round.
I think that's the problem. From what I understand, the Steeler's QB doesn't usually wear the gloves. Of course, with the weather they're expecting I would wear gloves...
He wears them when it's dry and cold!
Personally, I wish he NEVER wore them!!!