Replies

I'm not trying to be confrontational, but give me a rational explanation for how you think this would have a lasting positive outcome.

Well, FRiend, that was not the tack I was taking, but, OK, I'll bite for the sake of argument.

Islam is on the march against human civilization. This is a fight to the death, make no mistake. The fact is that the "holy" Koran clearly states that Mecca will never be conquered or destroyed because Allah (pig $hit be upon him) protects it.

If we turned their holy, unconquerable Mecca into a glowing crater, it might take the wind out of their sails. IOW they just might lose a lot of their stupid, blustering impetus to offer the last infidel the tender choice of a prayer rug or a coffin. Their primitive death cult might be exposed for the fraud that it is.

I'm not convinced your idea wouldn't work. I am also not convinced it would. You are expecting people to think rationally. "Allah said something totally wrong, so now I know Allah was full of it."

After watching the Palestinians follow a person who led them in the wildreness for fifty years, when there was an oasis to be had right under their feet, I'm just not convinced the subjects would come to the only conclusion you and I might.

The U.N., Europe, Russia, China, the whole Moslem world, even about half the U.S. populace would never respect this nation again.

We might be able to stiff the whole world today, but I see a time ahead when we're not going to be the top dog on the block. If we convince the world we are a paria state, I am not convinced that down the road we won't pay for it in ways we never thought possible.

I'm not saying I'd never buy into your plan, but it would take a catestrophic event to make it a viable option in my assessment. It would have to be done with the rest of the world's tacit approval. If not, we might just as will let the Islamics win. I think we'd lose in the long run anyway, due to massive disapproval of our actions.

Dittos on that. Nothing is for sure but my bet is nuking Mecca-Medina means no more Islam. So called god they call Allah cannot protect his most holy cities, then he ain't worth a damn. That's what most Muhammadans will conclude.