Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

U.S. Changes Arrest Techniques in Iraq ( Reducing actions considered humiliating by Iraqis )
Las Vegas Sun ^ | September 03, 2004 at 21:03:02 PDT | JIM KRANE

Posted on 09/03/2004 9:37:19 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach

BAGHDAD, Iraq (AP) -

The U.S. military is avoiding once-common arrest techniques like bagging suspects' heads, the U.S. commander in charge of the Iraqi capital said, because such actions are considered humiliating by Iraqis and pushing new recruits into the insurgency.

"You've got to see it from a force protection standpoint: You're making more enemies," U.S. Army Maj. Gen. Peter Chiarelli told The Associated Press. "When we mistreat one person I've got a net increase of nine enemies."

Soldiers are told to avoid handcuffing or blindfolding suspects - often done by placing a cloth sack over a suspect's head - in front of their families, said Chiarelli, who commands the Texas-based 1st Cavalry Division, which controls security in Baghdad.

The Army's 1st Infantry Division, which guards a swath of the Sunni Arab homeland north of Baghdad, started a similar "dignity and respect" initiative in April. Its commander, Maj. Gen. John Batiste, asked soldiers to be more courteous at traffic checkpoints and to stop putting bags over detainees' heads, division spokesman Maj. Neal O'Brien said.

Especially insulting is the practice of subduing Iraqi men by stepping on them.

"The worst thing in the world is to put him on the ground and put your boot on his head," Chiarelli said in an interview Thursday at 1st Cavalry headquarters near Baghdad International Airport. "Honor is so critical in this society. You don't take away a man's honor."

Baghdad residents, asked Friday about the changes, loosed a litany of complaints about the unpopular U.S. presence in Iraq, from the blocking of roads and bridges to aggressive driving and capricious detentions. Halting humiliating arrest techniques is a positive development, they said, but too little, too late.

"The detainee is not an animal to put a bag over his head," said Qusai Talha, a 35-year-old laborer interviewed at Tahrir Square in central Baghdad. "Detention should be done politely, until the prisoner is proven guilty - or not. The Americans should have considered this from the start."

"The Americans will only change Iraqis' opinions toward them when they leave Iraq," said Ahmed Kadhim, a 45-year-old teacher leaving a Shiite mosque in west Baghdad.

The division hired Iraqis to instruct the 32,000 U.S. troops under Chiarelli's command in the cultural traits and taboos of Iraq's 26 million inhabitants. Soldiers are told to separate a man being arrested from his family by asking him to go outside his home and speak to soldiers.

"If you really need to put him in flex cuffs, that's where you do it, not in front of his family," Chiarelli said.

About 10 percent of the division's troops "just don't get it," the commander said, but most understand the importance of treating Iraqis with dignity, even those accused of killing Americans or others. If soldiers humiliate a man being arrested in front of his family or neighbors, word spreads and hostility swells.

"It's not just a matter of being nice to the Iraqi people, it's clearly a force protection issue," Chiarelli said.

The arrest policy appears to conform with an emerging picture of Iraq's insurgency that paints it as a growing movement of nationalist Iraqis, angry at the presence of foreign troops.

U.S. and Iraqi officials have often underestimated the number of rebels and misleadingly described them as radical Islamists or foreign fighters vying to install a regime akin to Afghanistan's former Taliban government.

If ordinary Iraqis are tempted to join the guerrillas, U.S. troops would be wise to avoid provoking them.

"You can't allow (the insurgency) to get bigger. You can't let them recruit," Chiarelli said.

Chiarelli, 54, of Seattle, commands the third U.S. Army division to control security in the Iraqi capital. The 1st Cavalry has nearly completed half of its one-year stint in Baghdad.

The Iraqi capital's insurgency began to appear in mid-2003 under the yearlong tenure of the Germany-based 1st Armored Division, which turned the city over to the 1st Cavalry in April. Chiarelli said 1st Armored passed along some of its arrest techniques, which his division has since refined.

Under the general's orders, troops who violate Iraqi cultural norms are told to mitigate the damage by apologizing or offering to perform a favor for the offended family.

For instance, when soldiers raid a home by breaking down a door, a combat engineer is supposed to quickly fix the door, on the spot if possible. When the raid is a mistaken one, perhaps sparked by faulty intelligence, the attitude is supposed to be one of contrition.

"You say you're sorry when something bad occurs. You say 'Can we make up for the fact that we disturbed your family tonight?'" Chiarelli said. "'Can we come back and do anything for your family?'"

Chiarelli said he's had to adjust his own behavior. He greets Iraqi men with strong, warm handshakes, sometimes using both hands. If he's especially friendly with the man, Chiarelli said he follows the Iraqi custom - a smooch on both cheeks.

"I kiss them," he said.

But not Iraqi women.

"The biggest problem I have is when I meet women," he said. If a woman doesn't offer her hand, the general said he fights the urge to shake hands, forcing himself to keep his arms at his sides. He gives women a cursory greeting, avoiding looking into their eyes.

"If I did that in the States you'd call me a chauvinist pig," he said. "But that's their culture."

---

On the Net:

http://www.hood.army.mil/1stcavdiv

--



TOPICS: Extended News; Foreign Affairs; News/Current Events; War on Terror
KEYWORDS: iraq; muslimhonor

1 posted on 09/03/2004 9:37:19 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach

What a bunch of hothouse flowers those big, tough Iraqis are, huh?


2 posted on 09/03/2004 9:39:41 PM PDT by Hank Rearden (Never allow anyone who could only get a government job attempt to tell you how to run your life.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Hank Rearden

I don't understand the bags over the head being insulting. Have you ever seen a terrorist without a bag over his head? They are such cowards that they can't show their faces. So when US troops catch a terrorist do they put a bag over the bag?


3 posted on 09/03/2004 9:44:31 PM PDT by Oblongata
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach

Sounds like they are getting Americanized. Before you know it, they are going to get a lawyer and sue.


4 posted on 09/03/2004 9:45:09 PM PDT by microgood
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach

I guess I'm just being "insensitive," but frankly they're already coddled enough. Humiliation? How does one 'humiliate' a group that strips children, starves them of food and drink, makes them sit for days in absolute silence, then endangers them with bombs and cares not that those bombs cover them in blood and gore? Surely you jest! The only good terrorist is a dead terrorist. Humiliation? ROFL


5 posted on 09/03/2004 9:45:30 PM PDT by ETERNAL WARMING (He is faithful!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RealPiedPiper
So when US troops catch a terrorist do they put a bag over the bag?

LOL...Maybe they could just duct tape the eye and nose sections and save some money on buying head bags.
6 posted on 09/03/2004 9:48:48 PM PDT by microgood
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: microgood
Maybe they could just duct tape the eye and nose sections and save some money on buying head bags.

Or maybe they could just kick the terrorist bastards in the head until they can't be recognized by anyone, and thus won't be embarrassed.

7 posted on 09/03/2004 9:50:42 PM PDT by Hank Rearden (Never allow anyone who could only get a government job attempt to tell you how to run your life.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: ETERNAL WARMING
Well the commander did say this:

"It's not just a matter of being nice to the Iraqi people, it's clearly a force protection issue," Chiarelli said.

8 posted on 09/03/2004 9:54:07 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach (A Proud member of Free Republic ~~The New Face of the Fourth Estate since 1996.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach

POWER OF THE PRESS
Letter to a soldier from Dad
"We have recently had an issue involving the treatment of a few Muslim prisoners of war by a small group of our military police. These are the type prisoners who just a few months ago were throwing their own people off buildings, cutting off their hands, cutting out their tongues and otherwise murdering their own people just for disagreeing with Saddam Hussein. And just a few years ago these same type prisoners chemically killed 400,000 of their own people for the same reason. They are also the same type enemy fighters who recently were burning Americans and dragging their charred corpses through the streets of Iraq. And still more recently the same type enemy that was and is providing videos to all news sources
internationally, of the beheading of an American prisoner they held.

Compare this with some of our press and politicians who for several days have thought and talked about nothing else but the "humiliating" of some Muslim prisoners - not burning them, not dragging their charred corpses through the streets, not beheading them, but "humiliating" them. Can this be for real?"


9 posted on 09/03/2004 9:56:21 PM PDT by vivabushchick (To ensure we never offend anyone--like fanatics intent on killing us--no profiling will be allowed.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RealPiedPiper
About the first time one of the arrestees hurt or humiliated one of our soldiers,I would take in every Iraqi including the whole family...that was there and with some brutality..... then let that word spread.....
10 posted on 09/03/2004 9:58:46 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach (A Proud member of Free Republic ~~The New Face of the Fourth Estate since 1996.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: vivabushchick
Can this be for real?"

Power of the Press indeed is the reason!!!

11 posted on 09/03/2004 10:02:50 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach (A Proud member of Free Republic ~~The New Face of the Fourth Estate since 1996.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
"Like, totally bag yer face I am sure!"

-Valley Girl

Frank Zappa

12 posted on 09/03/2004 10:02:55 PM PDT by koolaidsmile ("Too weird to live, Too rare to die.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: microgood

PC will be the death of all of us.


13 posted on 09/03/2004 10:05:32 PM PDT by Let's Roll (Kerry accused countless soldiers of committing war crimes that he himself never witnessed . . .)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Hank Rearden
The arrest policy appears to conform with an emerging picture of Iraq's insurgency that paints it as a growing movement of nationalist Iraqis, angry at the presence of foreign troops.

This sounds like a reporters heartfelt opinion.... or simply doing his job as mandated by his boss...

14 posted on 09/03/2004 10:06:18 PM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach (A Proud member of Free Republic ~~The New Face of the Fourth Estate since 1996.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
"The worst thing in the world is to put him on the ground and put your boot on his head,"

IMHO, the worst thing in the world would be to apply too little force and be slaughtered by beheading by an Islamic fanatic who resisted arrest.

15 posted on 09/03/2004 10:12:31 PM PDT by Cvengr (;^))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach

Simple solution. Take no prisoners.


16 posted on 09/03/2004 11:10:06 PM PDT by Mr. Keys (Sensitive war? French recipe for disaster)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach

ill try it again,,, after over 20 years in the business i cant beleave im reading this.


17 posted on 09/03/2004 11:55:12 PM PDT by leaky acres mac
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
"Honor is so critical in this society. You don't take away a man's honor."

How about they carry special "Bullets of Honor" , and if the "perp" does not cooperate, they get asked politely whether they would like one.

18 posted on 09/04/2004 3:33:19 AM PDT by AmericaUnited (It's time someone says the emperor has no clothes.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson