Replies

Nazi Germany being a prime example... they used propaganda saying Jews were RATS... Jews are not human....

Nazi Germany had no free speech laws. Nobody could refute this viewpoint. There were no newspapers or radio shows giving different opinions.

If they same would happen today, everybody could disagree.

Violent or racist speech is no harm as long as everybody is free to disagree.

And video games, like anything that can be transmitted over a telephone line are "speech". Because it's entirely information which gets interpreted by the computer.

Isn't there a system on movies which rates them and prohibits minors form viewing them? Wouldn't that work with games also?

Speech and propaganda can have some major impact on society...

Only if there is just one version that gets repeated. Several propaganda shouters disagree with each other is no threat. Also, the constitution is for protecting the individual rights, not society's.

"Pulling together is the aim of despotism and tyranny. Free men pull in all kinds of directions."

I like how you handle the yourself... and actual debate/ discussion...

which leads me to some questions...

What about threats against the President? Is that against the Constitution? Or what about a threat to an individual? Are you allowed to do that?

But my major point is what you said... the Judge struck down the constitutionality of the games that minors can buy...

Why can't the state of Washington forbid the selling of games to minor... People over 17 could purchase them...

Isn't there a system on movies which rates them and prohibits minors form viewing them? Wouldn't that work with games also?

If these things were truly "protected speech", then any kind of rating system, or any legislative attempt whatsoever to keep them out of the view of minors, would be unconstitutional. Imagine someone trying to pass a law "protecting" minors from unpopular political views.

Movie ratings are strictly voluntary compliance. The only law backing them up is contract law because the studios get pretty mad if they get a lot of complaints about a theater not enforcing the ratings limitations. The ratings themselves have no legal authority, though x42 did talk about giving them some legal force for a couple days, his Hollywood budies seemed to have quickly talked him out of it though.