Posted on 05/29/2004 5:36:21 PM PDT by sarcasm
It is 1899 and Denzel Washington, the American president, orders Anne Frank and her troops to storm the beaches of Nazi-occupied New Zealand.
This may not be how you remember D-Day but for a worrying number of Britain's children this is the confused scenario they associate with the events of June 6, 1944.
|
|
|
|
A survey of 1,309 pupils aged between 10 and 14 and from 24 different schools found alarming levels of ignorance about the invasion of Normandy 60 years ago.
Only 28 per cent of primary and secondary pupils who sat the quiz last week were able to say that D-Day, involving the largest invasion force ever mounted, was the start of the Allied liberation of occupied western Europe.
Many of them could only say that it was something to do with the Second World War - though 26 per cent were flummoxed by even that fact. Some thought it took place in the First World War, or was the day war broke out, the Blitz and even Remembrance Sunday.
"It's a day when everyone remembers the dead who fought," said a 14-year-old girl at a north Devon secondary school. Only 16 per cent of 918 participating primary school children had the answer right.
One 10-year-old in a Northamptonshire school thought it was the day the "Americans came to rescue the English". Another thought D-Day involved "the invasion of Portsmouth". Various dates for the assault were 1066, 1776, 1899 and 1948.
Children also had great difficulty in naming Britain's war-time prime minister. Less than half of the overall sample and only 39 per cent of primary school children correctly identified him as Winston Churchill; a significant number opted for Margaret Thatcher or Tony Blair.
Seventeen per cent of the sample and only 38 per cent of secondary school children identified Franklin D Roosevelt as the then President of the United States. Other candidates offered by both age groups were Denzel Washington (the Oscar-winning actor), George Washington, John F Kennedy, Abraham Lincoln and George W Bush. Some said simply: "George Bush's dad."
Ignorance about the Allied leaders, however, contrasted sharply with knowledge about Adolf Hitler. Overall, 71 per cent of the sample and 64 per cent of primary school children were able correctly to name the Nazi leader. Only one in three could identify the broad location of D-Day, with a number saying that it happened in New Zealand, Skegness or Germany.
Thirteen per cent could name two of the beaches involved, and only 10 per cent of the sample knew that Dwight D Eisenhower was the Supreme Allied Commander. Others thought that the invasion was led by Anne Frank, Private Ryan (the eponymous hero of the Steven Spielberg D-Day epic), or Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery, Eisenhower's deputy.
The disclosure that school children know so little about D-Day comes a week before the country prepares to celebrate the anniversary and will again focus attention on what sort of history is being taught in schools.
Even in those schools where the Second World War is taught, the emphasis is not necessarily on military events or even wartime leaders. One primary school teacher said: "We do study the Second World War but we do not tend to concentrate on particular military events or leaders. We look at issues that are relevant to children themselves. They learn about evacuation for instance, or the issuing of gas masks."
Dr David Starkey, the historian and television broadcaster, said yesterday that the survey had uncovered what he called a climate of "unfortunately reduced horizons and expectations".
It was "absurd", he said, that children were spending so much time discussing Hitler and Stalin to the detriment of everything else connected with the war.
"There is nothing difficult about the concepts being discussed and no reason why a child of primary school age should not be able to understand."
He said that he did not want to go back to a situation where history teaching was nothing but dates and battles, but he said he feared that the pendulum had swung too far in the other direction.
"I think that trying to begin any subject by relating to a child's own experience is a useful tool. But education is about teaching children things they do not know."
Chris Grayling, the shadow education minister, said: "These are really very recent events that have shaped the lives of all of us.
"It is a real worry that so few children seem to know the basics of what happened during the Second World War. We must not allow this to continue."
There were some exceptions to the general ignorance. One teacher at Great Addington Church of England Primary school in Northamptonshire was amazed to find that one of his pupils had scored 100 per cent in the test.
He said: "I asked him how he knew material which we had not covered in school. He told me he had picked it up from a D-Day game he played on his computer."
It wouldn't be much better if you asked US school children the same questions.
It would be worse. Much worse. Replace Anne Frank with Paris Hilton.
Yeah, and George Patton was one of the Village People.
A few weeks ago, I ran into a neighbor of mine at a local mall. She was shopping for her seventeen-year-old daughter's upcoming high school graduation.
I mentioned that I was going to Normandy for the 60th anniversary of the D-Day invasion (leaving tomorrow as it turns out).
The girl didn't know about Normandy, didn't know what D-Day was, knew vaguely that there was a war between (not with) Japan and Germany, and didn't know the significance of any of this.
And this girl is valedictorian of her graduating class.
I had a secretary who, with completely sincerity, responded to something I said with "Hitler didn't like Jewish people?"
She now works in a public school (no kidding)
Or even worse, replace Anne Frank with Barney Frank, who mounted an assault from behind the enemy lines, and then liberated Matthew Shepard and his Jewish boyfriend from the Neocons.
This is in sharp contrast to the Muslims, who, even in their despotic, smelly, semi-educated hell holes, are very aware of their basic history, particularly of landmark triumphs, such as the defeat of the Crusaders by Saladdin, or the orgiastic massacre of Constantinople by the Ottomans.
I always knew when WWI was because my grandfathers were in it. I knew about WWII because my father and friends' fathers were in it. How much of this gross ignorance of RECENT history is due to the fact that the majority of children today do not grow up with their fathers, or even know who their fathers are?
American Kid: "D-Day was da Day that D-Diddy was Born."
American Kid: D-Day was the Day P Diddy was Born!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.