I didn't make any pre-speech comments on your thread, but I read all posts. I have to admit that I was pessimistic prior to the speech, thinking it was a no-win situation -- what could he say? But I was pleasantly surprised. I was particularly glad to see the President "put the ball back in the court" of the terrorists, by reciting the recent atrocities. He didn't exactly say that our prison indiscretions paled in comparison to the terrorists' actions, but the message came through loud and clear.
His emphasis on the role the Iraqi people must take -- it is, after all, their country -- was appropriate and well-stated.
Tough, tough situation. No way this was going to be a "feel good" speech. But under the circumstances, very well done, indeed.
Well, that is high praise coming from you! You always manage to be more objective than the rest of us -- and sometimes we don't like it........LOL.