Posted on 05/15/2004 4:14:35 PM PDT by Rennes Templar
The terrible death of Nick Berg in Iraq — beheaded in front of a video camera — has taken place in such strange and suspicious circumstances that it raises deeply troubling questions. Among them is whether American agencies had a direct or indirect hand in the young man’s murder.
Questions immediately arise from the timing and political consequences of his killing. At the height of a massive scandal engulfing the Bush administration, Berg’s death has been exploited by the American government and the US media to launch a counter-offensive against the revelations of systematic US torture in Abu Ghraib and other Iraqi prisons. A wholesale attempt is being made to shift American and international public opinion away from the outrage over the criminal character of the US occupation of Iraq and behind the self-serving argument that American forces are needed in Iraq to prevent the country descending into barbarism and chaos.
Were Berg’s murderers being directly paid by the American government, they could not have performed a more timely service for the Bush White House.
Berg’s killing was carried out in the name of al-Qaeda-aligned Jordanian terrorist Abu Musaab al-Zarqawi. Whoever is operating in the name of Zarqawi, they have a proven record of provocative actions that have only helped to prop up the American occupation of Iraq. On February 9, amid signs that the majority Iraqi Shiite population was on the verge of joining the armed resistance being fought mainly in Sunni Muslim areas, a letter was made public, allegedly authored by Zarqawi, calling for Sunnis to provoke a civil war with the Shiites. American officials used the letter to argue that their occupation was the only thing holding Iraq’s religious groups apart. Several weeks later, on March 2, suicide bombings at Shiite mosques in Karbala and Baghdad were blamed on what the US now calls the “Zarqawi network.”
Contrary to the schema outlined by US officials and in Zarqawi’s letter, the bulk of the Iraqi masses spurned sectarianism. The growing unity has been on display in mass demonstrations and joint struggle since the eruption of a Shiite uprising in early April. Even before the torture revelations, the US occupation of Iraq had crumbled into a morass of bloody reprisals against the Iraqi people and growing American casualties. Opposition has been steadily growing in the US and internationally.
The group who carried out the beheading of Berg and then ensured it was broadcast around the globe must have known that it would horrify American and world public opinion and assist the efforts at damage control in Washington.
Further questions are raised by the attempts of the US government to conceal or distort what it knew about Berg himself and the events leading up to his disappearance in Baghdad on April 10. Berg vanished in Iraq just 72 hours after being released from 13 days in US military custody and questioning by the FBI.
Berg has been described by his family and friends as adventurous. He had a limited knowledge of Arabic and an interest in obtaining reconstruction contracts in Iraq for the family telecommunications company, Prometheus Methods Tower Service. In December 2003 he travelled to Iraq and went home on February 1. Among the places the young man inquired for contract work was the Abu Ghraib prison—which he referred to as a “notorious prison for army and political prisoners.” He returned to Iraq in mid-March.
CBS News revealed yesterday that the young man had been on the FBI’s books for at least two years. In 2002, he was interviewed as part of the investigations in the September 11 terror attacks, over the fact his computer password had been used by alleged al-Qaeda terrorist Zaccarias Moussaoui. According to Berg’s family, the FBI was reportedly satisfied the password was obtained during a brief encounter on a bus, when Nick Berg had allowed an acquaintance of Moussaoui to use his computer.
On March 7, the pro-Bush website FreeRepublic.com published a list of “enemies” who were opposing the US occupation of Iraq. Among the names, taken from a public list of people who had endorsed a planned March 20 antiwar demonstration on the website of the group ANSWER, was Michael Berg—Nick’s father—and the name of the Berg family company. Such information would be entered into the databases of US intelligence agencies as well.
Berg was seized on March 24, within one week of returning to Iraq, and held incommunicado without charges in a Mosul prison for unspecified “suspicious activities.” His parents in Philadelphia were visited by the FBI on March 31 and asked why their son was in Iraq. Berg reported being interviewed at least three times during his detention by FBI agents and asked whether he had constructed pipe bombs or had visited Iran. He was released on April 6 only after his family filed a federal court case against the US government the day before for illegal imprisonment. Dan Senor, the Coalition Provisional Authority spokesman in Iraq, claimed this week that Berg had never been detained by US forces, only by Iraqis. This has been exposed to be a lie. Berg’s family has produced an email from Beth A Payne, a US consular official in Iraq, dated April 1. Payne wrote: “I have confirmed that your son, Nick, is being detained by the US military in Mosul... He was picked up approximately one week ago.” The chief of the Iraqi police in Mosul has also publicly rejected the claim that Berg was detained by his command. He told a press conference on May 13: “The Iraqi police never arrested the slain American. Take it from me... that such reports are baseless.”
After his release, Nick Berg travelled to Baghdad. His family last heard from him on April 9, when he reported he was looking to leave Iraq via Kuwait as soon as it was safe enough. They have indicated Berg told them he was wary of trying to fly out to Jordan on the grounds it was too dangerous. At the time, much of Baghdad was in engulfed in heavy fighting. Large parts of the city, including the roadways leading to the airport, were under constant attack by the Iraqi resistance and Westerners and Japanese had been taken hostage by various groups.
The last alleged contact with Berg by a US official was on April 10. A State department spokesperson told CBS an American diplomat offered to arrange a flight for him to Jordan. He allegedly refused and restated his intention to travel to Kuwait. His hotel has reported he left early on April 10, saying he intended to be back within a few days. If the American government is to be believed, no US agency then took any further interest in his activities or well-being until it was apparent he had disappeared. No satisfying answers have been given to obvious questions. Were Berg’s movements in Iraq being monitored by American intelligence? Why was he detained and on whose orders? Was he under surveillance after he was released on April 6? If he was, how did he come to be kidnapped in the centre of Baghdad? Throughout this week, Berg’s father Michael has repeatedly denounced the Bush administration for complicity in his son’s death. He told Boston radio station WBUR on Tuesday: “
[W]hat cost my son his life was the fact the US government saw fit to keep him in custody for 13 days without any of due process or civil rights and released him when they were good and ready. It goes further than Donald Rumsfeld. It’s the whole Patriot Act, it’s the whole feeling in this country that rights don’t matter any more because there are terrorists about. Well in my opinion ‘terrorist’ is just another word like ‘communist’ or ‘witch’ and it’s a witchhunt and this whole administration is just representing something that is not America.”
Yesterday, he told Philadelphia radio: “My son died for the sins of George Bush and Donald Rumsfeld. This administration did this.” He has also demanded to know whether “it is true that al-Qaeda offered to trade my son’s life for another person,” as is alleged in the video-tape statement of Nick Berg’s killers.
The issues being raised by Michael Berg point to the fact, that at best, the US authorities created the conditions in which his son could be kidnapped by extremists and killed.
The more disturbing possibility that arises from all the evidence that is known is that Berg’s disappearance and subsequent killing was the work of US agencies or pro-US Iraqi factions. One month after he disappeared, Berg was murdered at the most opportune moment for the US government.
Anyone who believes it is unthinkable or outrageous to suggest that the American government would sanction having one of its citizens murdered to shore up its fortunes is underestimating the political situation.
The Bush administration and elements of the American military hierarchy, media and corporate establishment are indictable war criminals. They ordered, directed, propagated or have profited from a criminal war, in flagrant violation of international law. The year since the US-led invasion of Iraq has been marked by further war crimes and atrocities. For significant sections of the American ruling class, everything depends upon preventing opposition to the occupation of Iraq within the American and international working class from developing into a conscious movement for political and social change. To them, the life of 26-year-old Nick Berg would have meant nothing.
Bump
"At the height of a massive scandal engulfing the Bush administration, "
I've been keeping up with the news well, but what massive scandal?
Do they mean that UN oil-for-food money ended up in the Bush administration???
It cant be that matter of a few guards humilation of some Iraqi prisoners. That was properly dealt with.
hmmmmmmmmmmm
"The Bush administration and elements of the American military hierarchy, media and corporate establishment are indictable war criminals. "
oh.
We ban trolls for saying stuff far far tamer than this lie...
Urban legends are starting...A teacher at my school thought the CIA killed him to cover up the prison scandal. "
NO. That teacher doesnt think that. That teacher is an Bush-hating liar who will take a slander and repeat to hurt a politician and cause (the CIA) the teacher dislikes.
Sad, really.
Consider the source huh? Sheesh!
Why are these people so overjoyed with it on one hand and refuse credit for it on the other?
>>Who IS responsible for Nick Berg's death:
1. Radical fundamentalist terrorists. <<
IMHO, should be changed to read:
"Who IS responsible for Nick Berg's death:
1. Radical ISLAMIC fundamentalist terrorists. "
Just thought I'd mention this. . .
Thanks for the addendum...
I accept and can't believe that I left that out...
I thought it was worth examining as it was published in the Tehran Times. If it were published only in the socialist publication where it orignated from then I would not deem it appropriate for FR.
Do we know for sure that Berg's lawsuit is the reason Nick was released? Could it have been just a coincidence?
What is sad, is the kids. I'm just a substitute, but I see so much dumbing down that it is crippling our future. We might have "No child left behind", but the parents do not want to get involved with their childrens education. I work in a low income area. We had to pledge alliance to the flag this morning and most of students just sat in thier chairs or just hestitated and look around afraid. Out of curiosity, I asked the students why they didn't want to say the pledge. I was hoping to hear they are Jovah Witnesses or some other religious affiliation. No, it was the left wing rant. A girl screamed out that this country is no good and people don't have equal rights...blah...blah. They were surprised they had a Bush supporter as a substitute. I asked her, if she doesn't like it here...why doesn't she move? The kids giggled. I told them they are spoiled and take their freedoms for granted. My husband port of call was Istanbul,Turkey. Don't poke fun at statues of historical leaders or you could be arrested. If your a student in Iran protesting against the establishment, you might go to jail. She blamed Bush for the War in Iraq. We should be helping our own people who don't have anything and not spend the money on the Iraqis. I told her, if we don't help the Iraqi's the terrorist will be at our shores again to bomb us to financial ruin with no social programs. Pretty soon they were chanting KKK and all the sterotypes they give to Republicans. They were just acting silly. I started to ask very simple questions about our society. Do you like to shop? If the terrorist damage our infrastruture then we are not able to get consumer goods or food. We depend on shipping, our ports and trucking. How would you like to wait in line for loaf of bread? They told me they wait in line in the school cafeteria. Do you like your Nike shoes? I like to buy my Nike shoes and I want them when I demand them. I asked them how would they handle if the terrorist attacked like they did on 911 but with more destruction, how would they cope with the slaughter? Some kids listen but most were oblivious to anything harmful. These kids take everything for granted and do not appreciate all the freedoms we do have. Freedom without appreciation is the death of our nation.
I did help a kid today. He was having problems with his Algebra and we worked it out. He felt so good tackling all his problems and getting the problems right! A little elbow grease goes a long way.
Your comments about kids scare me.
It is sad that kids are like this.
We must be doing something absolutely amazing with our kids. They are 8 and 6 and (so far) are nothing like that.
Thankfully, my wife and I are both resolved to raise good moral, non-bratty, non-liberal kids. Both got straight As this year... So far so good. :-)
Boys - listen up a little, ok?
Do some research at www.google.com. Read around that site. Learn how to really find what you're looking for. You can do it. One can search google and find just about anything you want to.
Preferences.
(Just a thought... a teacher at my school... 'the CIA killed him'"
Huh? What kind of teacher is that?????)
- hey bud, your teacher is on crack or something.
I guarantee at this very moment some Hollyweirdo is writing the screenplay and it'll air in August on ABC.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.