Of course not. Only a buffoon would seriously consider such a thing. islam, in it's current state is the enemy, not the people that practice it.
I would go so far as to say kill everyone who raises a hand in anger against the West, in general, and the US specifically. I would also say that any imam or ilsamist that promotes violence against the West, and the US specifically, becomes fair game, as well. Kill enough of the radicals and those that truely want islam to change (if there are any) can be heard.
Make no mistake about it. The US and Western civilization is in a battle to the death with islam. It ends one of three ways. The West loses and the world is plunged into another dark ages. The islamists lose to the "moderate" moslems, and islam is reformed into a true religion that can peacefully co-exist with other reilgions. Lastly, islam fails to reform, and the West is forced, out of neccesity, to eradicate islam as an ideology.