Replies

In fact, we probably don't even have the whole of his answer as all we have read is an article by a 3rd person who quotes portions of the interview.

The whole article is over here if anyone is concerned about the excerpting.

Is the Pope Catholic...Enough? as well at the NYT website.

As I've noted before, Hutton is a public figure in his own right, he's written two books, a newsletter, and speaks publicly. Personally, I think the NYT quotes are enough to identify him as a revisionist, and since you properly note his views aren't necessarily his son's, I'm not sure it makes sense to load the thread with comments from Hutton and his supporters.

As I've noted before, Hutton is a public figure in his own right, he's written two books, a newsletter, and speaks publicly. Personally, I think the NYT quotes are enough to identify him as a revisionist

And, in light of this being about the only online publication with his remarks, I'm willing to stipulate for the sake of this discussion that you are probably correct.

I'm not sure it makes sense to load the thread with comments from Hutton and his supporters.

Thank you for a voice of sanity. Let's look at Mel's record. His father's record is not germaine to this discussion. Maybe if Mel were making a movie about the Holocaust it would be, but, he's not.