[Southack]

Bush's plan also requires that they all go home voluntarily after three years in order to apply for new extensions to work here. That form of voluntary self-deportation is precisely what Sabertooth is calling for in his editorial for this thread above, though he like you seems to be against Bush's plan that does that very thing.

"Incorrect, there is no such requirement." - Sabertooth

Then we disagree on a fact. One of us must be wrong, and that error will impact the rest of our logic, one presumes.

That is a key point worth resolving.

[ninenot]

It's resolved. See my post from ZaZona/CATO. There IS NO REQUIREMENT FOR ANYONE TO GO HOME, and there is NO END to renewals of permits.